How Fish is Made: The Game That Perfected Surreal Horror
394K views · May 10, 2025 · Gaming
Comments · 456
@minaxa · 1 year ago · pinned
This is a reupload! Refer to my community post as to the reason why, but I had issues uploading originally and the video didn't perform well. I wanted to give the video another shot because I know it deserved better, so here you go!
836
@soup_minnow_ · 1 year ago
shoutout to the fact that jimmy's crimes are never explicitly stated throughout the dlc, as well as curly being the only mouthwashing character that shows up explicitly, almost paralleling the fact that Jimmy, despite everything that happens, continues to think that Curly is the only one he wronged, ignoring and refusing to acknowledge the other crew members and the harm he caused them
3.7K
@mehmeh3894 · 1 year ago
The eye things (actually lotus roots) saying “you’ll be back” is a reference to how you, the player, are definitely playing through again to try the other ending, hence returning to the room.
1.8K
@zirotsero6951 · 1 year ago
Apparently, mouthwashing has an in universe book called "up or down." I personally interpret the events of the game to be the book, and the dlc to take place in curly's mind, using the book as a setting
1K
@beastvg123 · 1 year ago
In terms of fish, there's a huge amount of evidence that suggests that fish, do, in fact, feel pain. Neuroscience and biology show us that some species of fish pass the mirror test, have rich social lives, and exoerience the world in many ways we cannot even imagine. Fish show goal directed behavior, valenced states, complex communication and mating behavior, etc.
614
@Многокартошка · 1 year ago
I like how the colour of down/up changes<br>the colour blue gives a feeling of safety as if it is right, and it changes right when you are introduced a new idea along with it. I think it makes it more likely you wont stick with your first answer
730
@THEJackMerridew · 8 months ago
I feel like the louse and the tongueless fish is a (very vague) reference of Jimmy and Curly. As Curly, after the accident, is unable to speak and Jimmy (the parasite) speaks for him and effectively… takes over the role of Curly
47
@faerielixie · 1 year ago
I do believe the two fish are a representation of daisuke and swansea, and the link between the second fish and daisuke is bigger than you'd think once you think about it. The fish talks about how it was never meant to be there, possibly alluding to how daisuke was a last minute addition to the crew and therefore not given a cryo pod. The fish also says that it misses the previous choice it had, even if it was scary. In the scene where daisuke is drunk venting he mentions his mom chose the internship for him because he was never good at anything and had no idea what to do with his life - the choice of a career path scared him. Finally, the fish's lines where it says "nothing can stop us if we're together! you're just like me, take me with you" could have two different meanings. First, the friendship between daisuke and jimmy (see: the yimpy post it, and how jimmy is kinder to daisuke than to the rest of the crew), or second, which i think is more likely, the way daisuke needed an older mentor's guidance and depended on swansea and jimmy. I also like your theory about the two sides of jimmy's ego though!! this was a great video analysis and i like how you simplified the meaning of how fish is made because i didn't understand it at first XD
476
@Yammy8Sammy · 1 year ago
I dont think Curly is a filthy monster on par with Jimmy.. cause hes not, but its frustrating thinking of how easily he could have stopped everything. You’d expect him to do better. Youd expect the guy with your life in his hands to do better. Anya told Curly what happened because she trusted him as a friend, an equal, but it clearly wasn’t really mutual seeing how he just left her hanging alone and knew the whole time.
451
@tenta9876 · 1 year ago
<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BcVDIGqqsU&t=752">12:32</a> hope other people didn't comment this yet but those are the discs lotuses have their seeds in! They bloom with the pretty pink flowers over the water and mud. Very cool making the seeds all grotesque and weird.
650
@straight-up479 · 1 year ago
BE A DOWNCHAD DONT LISTEN TO THE UPCELS. STAY DOWNPILLED, DONT LOSE YOUR WAY. IGNORE THE UPSLOP PROPAGANDA. DOWNERS STAY ON TOP.
561
@Leximations095 · 1 year ago
I was deadass in the middle of watching your original video, and then I refreshed YouTube and saw this
846
Up next

How Mouthwashing Perfected Psychological Horror
minaxa · 1.2M views

Revisiting Gemini: Losing What Makes Us Human
minaxa · 1.3M views

A Research Station Went Dark In The Andes Mountains. The Reason Why Is Horrifying. | Creepypasta
Scary JUJU · 164 views

Dreams of an Insomniac: An Analog Horror Enigma
minaxa · 594K views

The Quest to Perfect Five Nights at Freddy's (FULL SERIES)
minaxa · 1.2M views

MyHouse.WAD - Inside Doom's Most Terrifying Mod
Power Pak · 19M views

The Dark Conspiracy Behind A Screensaver...
Sagan Hawkes · 981K views

Why Did We Forget Baldi's Basics? (A Retrospective)
minaxa · 4.2M views

Can You Kill EVERYTHING In Fear & Hunger?
Connorsseur · 458K views

The Quest to Perfect Ultimate Custom Night
minaxa · 934K views

I played Zoochosis so you don't have to
anxietony · 1.3M views

Five Nights at Candy's Is Kinda Awesome.
minaxa · 4.3M views

Revisiting Local58: The Original Analog Horror
minaxa · 2.1M views

The Horror Game About Friendship
halfbrewed · 284K views

Midwest Angelica: The Most Underrated Analog Horror
minaxa · 424K views

A Complete Story Breakdown of SIGNALIS
Indie Xplorer · 852K views

Why One Night at Flumpty's is Kinda Perfect.
minaxa · 3.2M views

How Lacey Games Explores Girlhood Trauma
minaxa · 3.7M views

The Horrifying Game That Doesn’t Exist | The World of Godhusk
Dogma · 1.6M views

Indigo Park is What Mascot Horror Should Be
minaxa · 903K views

I attempted the Hardest Nuzlocke in Gaming
The Grim Kleaper · 3.5M views

A Digital Horror Tragedy - Milton Math Games Explained
minaxa · 1.1M views

Liminal Land | The Cult Hiding in an Amusement Park
Crowmudgeon · 995K views

How Survival Horror's Greatest Monster Was RUINED
Pastra · 2.6M views

Pathologic is Genius, And Here's Why
hbomberguy · 13M views

The Redemption of Five Nights at Treasure Island
minaxa · 1.9M views