Two Mysteries That Will Make You Question Everything
353K views · Dec 9, 2025 · Entertainment
Comments · 330
@igoracin14 · 7 months ago
I would like to think that Dorothy “disappeared” and became a new person living the life she wanted and even published work under her new name❤
323
@theknight3583 · 9 months ago
Oh how doth the past adore blaming women for things and calling them witches... How could they ignore the sailor knot on the restraints?? Botched for sure
237
@Bibliophelle · 9 months ago
As a fellow writer who also feels like my parents will never truly want to know ME and not their idea of me, my heart aches for Dorothy. Thank you for telling her story.
235
@rainpuddles7239 · 9 months ago
Dorothy Arnold could have used a false name to get a train ticket. Back then you didn't have to prove who you were. You could just walk up and buy a ticket.
441
@simianbarcode3011 · 9 months ago
"...my para-social historical enemy, P.T. Barnum..." 😂SAME
134
@TheFireflyGrave · 9 months ago
I'd be curious to read Dorothy Arnold's stories. Wikipedia points to one story, "The Poinsettia Flames," but I can't find any evidence it still exists.
159
@hms_maeflower · 6 months ago
An abortion would explain her selling her jewelry to pay for it.
39
@user-zu1py7kv2q · 9 months ago
You know the fact she bought a new book IS chilling. If she knew it was her last day, she would have had her favorite book or she would have written something herself.
86
@missyannp36 · 9 months ago
First time listening. Our cat's name is Jinxy and every time you say Jinx, she looks around. HAHA
87
@andrewgilbert4659 · 9 months ago
You should (at least occasionally) bring the full intro back. It's honestly one of the best mood setting dialogues I've ever heard in an intro.
178
@AuDDMama · 6 months ago
So sad Dorothy couldn't just run away and marry the man she actually loved, raise their child and write for the rest of her life! Her family was screwed up.
12
@kelseycoca · 7 months ago
I wonder if "the accident" is a reference to a pregnancy?<br>the scandal!
84
Up next
Reddit Scary Stories: Djinn, Doppelgängers, and Imaginary Friends (feat. Two Girls One Ghost)
Heart Starts Pounding w/ Kaelyn Moore and Two Girls One Ghost · 373K views
Halloween Horror: She Lured Men to Her Farm... None of Them Left Alive
Heart Starts Pounding w/ Kaelyn Moore · 146K views
Two Shipwrecks. Same Island. Completely Different Outcomes | Kaelyn Moore
Dark Clues Kaelyn Moore · 9.4K views
The Crime That Changed Everything: Blaze Bernstein
Clues with Kaelyn Moore · 239K views
These True Listener Stories Get Darker Every Minute | Kaelyn Moore
Dark Clues Kaelyn Moore · 15K views
He Died and Saw Everything Before Life on Earth (Aaron Green NDE)
NDE Mystery Diaries · 1.4M views
The Nightshift ENTITY That Paralyzed THREE People
Roanoke Tales · 3.9K views
Australia's Most Haunting Cold Case: The Beaumont Children
Heart Starts Pounding w/ Kaelyn Moore · 243K views
This hotel room ruined their lives...
MrBallen · 1.3M views
When Polygamists Wives Hit Back (ft. @Cults to Consciousness)
Amanda Rae · 43K views
Joyce LePage: A Secret Dorm, an Abandoned Car and a Missing Student
Crime Junkie · 124K views
Halloween Horror: H.H. Holmes Murder Castle
Heart Starts Pounding w/ Kaelyn Moore · 136K views
Jack the Ripper Was NEVER Caught… Here's Why
Clues with Kaelyn Moore and Crime House · 157K views
Happy Updates Only.. || Reddit Stories || Two Hot Takes Podcast
Two Hot Takes · 354K views
3 Cold Cases That Were Solved With INSANE Twists
Heart Starts Pounding w/ Kaelyn Moore and Clues Pod with Morgan Absher & Kaelyn Moore · 376K views
Clairvoyants, Ghosts & the Thinning Veil || True Scary Stories From Listeners
ashleeinc · 153K views
Stairway to Heaven Backmasking, Lavender Town & Creepy Reddit Stories | Internet After Dark 002
Macabre Mondays · 1.1K views
She Left a Note That Said 'Run.' Then She VANISHED.
Heart Starts Pounding w/ Kaelyn Moore · 394K views
True Poltergeist Horror Story | The Great Amherst Mystery | When a Ghost Tries to Kill (Ep 392)
Two Girls One Ghost · 71K views
The Truth Behind the Salem Witch Trials
Clues with Kaelyn Moore · 209K views
Halloween Horror: The Darkest Unsolved Murder in German History
Heart Starts Pounding w/ Kaelyn Moore · 137K views
The Murder that Divided America's Richest Town
Heart Starts Pounding w/ Kaelyn Moore · 242K views
Reddit Scary Stories with Morgan Absher & Kaelyn Moore | Appalachia, Bigfoot & Horrors (Ep 383)
Two Girls One Ghost and Heart Starts Pounding w/ Kaelyn Moore · 482K views
3 Hours of Disturbing Stories That Keep Getting Worse
Lets Read! · 216K views
craziest reddit stories that broke the internet | Charlotte Dobre TV
Charlotte Dobre TV · 507K views
Ep. 711 | The Lie Was in His Stomach - MrBallen
MrBallen’s Medical Mysteries Podcast · 81K views