Problematic Hadith about Apostasy | Part 13 | Dr. Shabir Ally

Comments · 518

• CH

  @ChrisChidi-i1g · 6 months ago

  Again we ask, "Why will the truth need the threat of death to keep you believing"

  10

• LA

  @lahleholivia7398 · 3 years ago

  Why would the truth need the threat of death to keep you believing??

  126

• AL

  @al-hassan9200 · 2 years ago

  Dr. Shubir is a very serious intellectual for giving this insight into this troubling subject and tackling this matter with such genuine scepticism and to be this open and frank with his followers - that &nbsp;he knows full well that they will slam him with all sorts of accusations - <br>Salute to him for this remarkable take 🙏

  26

• DA

  @davids8177 · 3 years ago

  Thank you Dr. Shabir for this explanation. It is so rare to find a Muslim scholar with the courage to speak the obvious about these Hadith corruptions which denigrate the prophet Mohammad and Islam. The Quran is clear and unambiguous that there is no compulsion in religion. One has to be completely blind to miss this. The problem with most hadith followers is that they almost always take the Hadith over the Quran. They fail to use their reason and think, which is the exact mentality the Quran repeatedly warns against. Blindly following traditions without thinking. Killing another human being is a major sin. Do these people think that a judgement/law as important as life or death would be absent from the Quran?

  61

• SI

  @Simarodra · 3 years ago

  &quot;we respect them but ...&quot;, ustadzun I learned from use the same format when they disagree with a scholar or other ustadz. &quot; ... but I am more incline toward ... for the reason of ... and referring to the kitaab of .... &quot;. <br><br>Differences presented that way stimulated healthy conversation and thinking. Thank you Dr. Shabir... 🙏

  9

• CH

  @charlievaughan1308 · 2 years ago

  As &nbsp;an Irishman who &nbsp;was brought &nbsp;up Catholic but is now agnostic, i realy enjoyed your talk, Dr.Shabir.<br>As an Imam &nbsp;i have profound respect for your views. Wishing you peace and joy.

  61

• QU

  @QuranforTheWest · 3 years ago

  Great work Dr. Shabir and Dr. Saffiyah

  10

• DA

  @Dante_Alighatori · 3 years ago

  No hadith can go against the authority of the Quran. Very well explained.

  96

• CC

  @ccx9562 · 3 years ago

  It is not only one Quranic verse but more vi than 50 ayats that confirm the freedom of religion,but of course Sunnis and Shia muslims do not follow the Quran.They follow their hafiths,each their special collection.They abandoned Quran 13 centuries ago,and that is the tragedy of the ummah.

  9

• CH

  @christopherahmed8961 · 2 years ago

  Hope people see this after viewing the PBD podcast.

  2

• OP

  @opimusno12012 · 3 years ago

  Hats off sir. Finally a real muslim who is bringing better intellect. i would like to hear you more. May be Ghamidi sahab and you are more enlightened

  48

• AL

  @al-hassan9200 · 2 years ago

  THIS MAN GIVES ME HOPE ❤

  8