NEW SERIES! How Should Muslims View Hadith? | Dr. Shabir Ally

Comments · 148

• BO

  @bodymind195 · 3 years ago

  Along with dr Sabir we must appreciate the contribution by this woman scholar in enlightening the Ummah in this difficult times

  13

• YS

  @YSl11 · 3 years ago

  The overlords of Sunni Islam will not dare to remove a hadith with questionable content. <br><br>If people begin to question the authenticity of the chains, then the whole narrative falls apart. &nbsp;They can’t let go of their control and let the Quran free people as it is meant to!!<br><br>Thank you Dr. Shabbir Ally!! It’s time to break the chains!!

  28

• ME

  @MemorialDr · 3 years ago (edited)

  Dr Shabbir Ally specifically mentions Ayesha RA age at marriage as 9 Hadith problematic. &nbsp; I used to be confused on this as well. &nbsp; In another book I read her age was around 30 same as Hafsa RA as she was present in a battle helping wounded soldiers and 9 year old would be too young to be present in the battlefield.<br><br>Just sharing my opinion here as I came to another conclusion. &nbsp; This is just my own personal opinion you may use it if you like to reconcile it. &nbsp; The Arabs had a different method of counting ages for females. &nbsp; The 9 years refers to years after her period or when she became adult. &nbsp;The way they measured ages for females was different back then. &nbsp; So if she got her period at 18, her actual age was 27. &nbsp; Or period at 14, her actual age was 23. &nbsp; &nbsp;Keeping in mind story of her presence in battle period at 21 actual age 30. &nbsp; In essence her real age is unknown and definitely not 9 as mentioned in the hadith. &nbsp;<br><br>Allah knows best!!!!<br><br>Excellent series this will be. &nbsp; And much needed.

  11

• HA

  @Hassan_Omer · 3 years ago (edited)

  Thank you Dr. Shabir and Dr. Safiyyah for talking about this subject, jazakAllah khairan.

  11

• TH

  @thetruth27786 · 3 years ago

  Ive been waiting again for this....the last series on hadeeth use did couple of years ago has truly helped me and i make dua for use whenever i can.Cant wait for more vids on this

  8

• SA

  @sarahalhulail4928 · 3 years ago

  Thank you both. You are doing very crucial work at this time in our Islamic history in such a gentle reasonable manner.

  4

• AM

  @amanaashraf1899 · 3 years ago

  could you do marriage series-how to choose a spouse,purpose,Islamic way of nikkah,fiqh of mahr etc

  4

• DE

  @defeatedpoet6377 · 3 years ago

  Looking forward to this new series. Thank you for making it happen.

  4

• US

  @user-k229 · 3 years ago

  We have abandoned the Quran in favour of man-made hadith!<br>The hadith to the Muslims, without realising it, are. just like the Gospels!<br>The Gospels are according to Mathew, Mark, Lake and John. The hadith are those according to Bukhari! He was born, in what is modern day Iran, Persian.

  9

• AH

  @ahmfarooq1823 · 3 years ago

  How is it possible for a man like Imam Bukhari who is from Uzbekistan, 4500 km from Mecca to collect 6,00,000 hadiths and sorted these out, prove thieir authenticity in those days of rough communication systems? If he had to do this he would have to live thousands of years. And most importantly those were not written documents. However, he rejected 99% of those hadiths. What the hadith followers term ‘science of hadith’ is absurd. There followed no scientific process there. And why they don’t believe the hadith where the Prophet(pbuh) prohibited hadith writing?

  5

• ME

  @mekhimkl2702 · 3 years ago

  I appreciate the way that your thinking continues to evolve on this and other matters. It shows that you do as we are commanded to do: READ. STUDY. THINK CRITICALLY. and ALWAYS ORIENT BACK TO THE QURAN.

  2

• LA

  @larryhassan2889 · 3 years ago

  Allah bless Dr Sabir and am happy finally this topic is here for us to learn

  2