How Did We Miss This?! Our Tarnished is More Than They Seem. Elden Ring Lore Theory No DLC Spoilers
1.1M views · Jun 8, 2024 · Gaming
Comments · 5K
@ZayftheScholar · 2 years ago (edited) · pinned
Hi guys! Wanted to sneak in another video before the DLC drops! Only pertains to the base game so watch without worry. Curious to know what you guys think!<br><br>Edit: People are commenting mad about spoilers...bros it's the opening cinematic. I didn't think it needed spoiler warnings 😅
1.3K
@delfean2666 · 2 years ago
The more lore videos I watch, the bigger Marika's body count gets
20K
@ceaga90 · 2 years ago
Does this mean every time I see “YOU DIED” the random soldier that kills me sees “DEMIGOD SLAIN”?
7.5K
@ThePandaOfYourMind · 2 years ago
Can we all agree that whatever our tarnished is, they are the most terrifying thing in the lands between. Imagine the demigods and you see this functionally immortal creature who's only purpose is to kill you, and they will, because you can never permanently destroy them. The tarnished is like a fantasy terminator.
10K
@omaralmubayd · 1 year ago
If the tarnished is a demigod, then we are the outer god controlling him
1.8K
@demonkingsparda · 2 years ago
The big problem with this theory is that now a decent chunk of Marika porn needs to be tagged as incest
5.9K
@GideonOfnirTheAllCoping · 2 years ago
The fact that Melina and Ranni both take note of you at the beginning of the game and give you things (Torrent, spirit summons) also suggests that your Tarnished is a pre-existing character and not just some random guy.
8.3K
@TheGuardingDark_ · 2 years ago
“RADAGON! You’re son has returned! I bring the destruction of Leyndell!
732
@circleman4202 · 1 year ago
<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wmjo72GiLRk&t=424">7:04</a> it was me, I did it.
28
@thevestere · 2 years ago
Holy shit this makes so much sense. <br>Marika states that her children that do not amount to anything would be cast aside. <br>If we're a Tarnished of NO renown it would follow that we were punished for not making something of ourselves if we were in fact a Demigod.<br><br>"But should ye fail to become aught at all, ye will be forsaken. Amounting only to sacrifices..."
3.6K
@777Looper · 2 years ago (edited)
I like that this makes Gideon "The All-Knowing" Ofnir less ludicrusly uninformed. <br><br>He did know, in his bones, that a Tarnished could not become the Elder Lord. <br><br><br>Our bones received no such memo.
2.8K
@seetinq · 2 years ago (edited)
So what you're telling me is... we either marry our mom or sister, if we chose anything other than the frenzied flame ending...
4.2K
Up next

Investigating Elden Ring's WEIRDEST Weapon
Zayf the Scholar · 368K views

The REAL reason Radahn Stopped the Stars - Elden Ring Lore Theory & Speculation
Zayf the Scholar · 613K views

Why Elden Ring sold 30 million copies
Games That Sold · 4.3K views

Melina's Room is the CRAZIEST spot in Elden Ring... Lore Theory & Speculation
Zayf the Scholar · 520K views

Why It Sucks To Be Born As A Tarnished
game.mp4 · 1.6M views

Godwyn's Corruption is WORSE Than You Know - New Discoveries at the Erdtree's Roots Elden Ring Lore
Zayf the Scholar · 378K views

Leontiel Led Me to a Something INSANE... Elden Ring Investigation
Zayf the Scholar · 152K views

Prisoner Theory | Elden Ring Philosophical Dissection
Dareloth · 936K views

Who is Truly the Strongest Souls Protagonist?
Brollo · 1.9M views

Unraveling the CREEPIEST Mystery in Elden Ring - Godwyn's Mermaid Metamorposis
Zayf the Scholar · 629K views

Godwyn's NEW lore is WEIRDER than you think...- Elden Ring DLC Lore Theory & Analysis
Zayf the Scholar · 469K views

The Lore of Elden Ring is in Ruins
VaatiVidya · 2.8M views

Midra and Malenia’s HORRIFYING Connection - The Creepy Details You Missed Elden Ring Lore Theory
Zayf the Scholar · 193K views

The Elden Ring Theory Iceberg
Miss Chalice · 794K views

Nothing makes sense without him | Elden Ring Lore
Hawkshaw · 515K views

The Hornsent gate of divinity wasn't the first | Elden Ring Lore
The Alchemist · 81K views

The True Size of the Elden Ring Map, or: Don't Trust Everything You Read on the Internet
Addypalooza · 1.6M views

Unraveling the Disturbing Curse of Stormveil Castle in Elden Ring – Lore Theory and Speculation
Zayf the Scholar · 743K views

Lore of the Main Bosses in Elden Ring
ZeeVoke · 6.1M views

Between Meanings: The Impossible Sun | Elden Ring Lore
SilentEllipsis · 100K views

Why The Gods Were Terrified Of The Tarnished | Elden Ring Lore
Unknown Elden · 7.6K views

The Lore of Elden Ring is FOUL
VaatiVidya · 4.1M views

Elden Ring - Ranni's Different Reactions To Meeting You
RolledOrso · 582K views

15 Fabulous Secrets in Elden Ring!
VaatiVidya · 3.9M views

The Complete Grand Unified Theory of Elden Ring - Lore Remastered
SilentEllipsis · 635K views

How Big is the Architecture in Elden Ring? (Real World Comparisons)
Addypalooza · 1.8M views