The Dumbest FNAF Debate Ever... (and how I solved it)

Comments · 631

• WI

  @WitheredCircle · 6 months ago · pinned

  GET 10% OFF YOUR NEXT MANTASLEEP PURCHASE -&gt; <a href="https://mantasleep.pxf.io/190KjR">https://mantasleep.pxf.io/190KjR</a><br>Thanks for watching, leave your thoughts in the comments :)

  69

• MR

  @mrkimitsu · 6 months ago (edited)

  The Unwithered Truth when the Withered Lie walks in.

  1.1K

• JP

  @jpfan4life812 · 6 months ago (edited)

  Except the Unwithereds being Fiona&apos;s designs makes no sense when they are objectively creepier than the classics. The classics being Fiona&apos;s designs and the unwithereds being the new concepts that Edwin calls creepy lines up with what phone guy said about the withereds being ugly. Plus, the unfinished prototypes seen in the MCM&apos;s R&amp;D wing resemble the classics.

  620

• FR

  @FREDDN87 · 6 months ago

  Withered... Freddy? Withered.... Circle... Withered Donut...

  576

• AR

  @arielalvarado2842 · 6 months ago

  i think that fionas design were the classics. The phone guy describes the withered as ugly and so does edwin when referring to the ones fazbear wanted him to make. He flat out says that he wasn’t changing the designs, I PERSONALLY believe the classics were fiona’s designs.

  894

• CO

  @conflictt3224 · 6 months ago (edited)

  The only part I disagree with is the Unwithereds being Fionna&apos;s designs. Edwin calls out the new ones William and Henry sent him looking creepy, so it makes more sense for the obviously more creepy and uncanny looking Unwithereds to be the ones William and Henry wanted. Which is why they went back to those designs when they started from scratch for the FNAF2 location, before realizing everyone also hated them and making the Toys, and later reverting to Fionna&apos;s designs for the FNAF1 reopening. This would also be backed up by the &apos;hinge jaw&apos; theory, where the hinged jaw designs which pop up in UCN and on are either a Henry or William design motiff- hence the Unwithereds having it too.

  282

• CE

  @cephlo4933 · 6 months ago

  First theory were I&apos;m adamantly against it, since Fiona is emphasized to have created the classic designs whereas Henry/William made the &quot;frankly creepy&quot; Unwithered designs. This is much more apparent with Pizza simulator with the Mediocre&apos;s and Rockstars having Henry&apos;s design trait of having unhinged/segmented jaws compared to the classics connected jaw. Plus it&apos;d makes sense for the art and the merch to have been curated by Fiona first, but then inexplicably making the animatronics look different due to Henry/William&apos;s design taking priority. Then switching over to the classic design to reopen into the smaller location in Fnaf 1. Giving a reason as to why there&apos;s plushies and art of classics in 1983-87.

  166

• TL

  @tlkformerly · 6 months ago

  <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NGfBg_c2rnE&amp;t=95">1:35</a> &quot;Withered Bonnie&apos;s face didn&apos;t match up&quot; what face

  121

• LO

  @Lockendrik · 6 months ago

  Here&apos;s what I believe:<br>Fiona designed the classics, Henry designed the withereds, Edwin wants to keep Fiona&apos;s designs, William and Henry basically steal Fiona&apos;s design without paying them anything.

  129

• WE

  @WestonNewbell · 6 months ago

  I feel like the phone call alone pretty clearly establishes that the unwithered existed

  107

• BO

  @bob171 · 6 months ago

  What even is this argument? The withered animatronics literally exist in FNAF 2, so why would a fixed version of them not exist??

  16

• CH

  @Cheeseburger1962 · 6 months ago

  I guess you could say this is the <b>truth</b> of the <b>Unwithereds</b>

  86