Responding to Gavin Ortlund on the Papacy
111K views · Oct 22, 2025 · Education
Comments · 1.5K
@Andrew-ps6xe · 11 months ago
Last time I was this early, Catholic and Orthodox were the same church.
474
@darthvader2506 · 11 months ago
You know its a good day when Mr. Trent Horn uploads! Still praying for Mrs. Horn!
468
@TheVeilandtheVine · 11 months ago
I so love that you're having your scripts reviewed because they can no longer claim "straw man" when you critique them.
755
@danielsanchez-sq3hq · 11 months ago
Even if you most likely don’t see this — thank you, Trent! The Counsel of Trent challenged me to think more deeply and clearly about my faith. Your reasoned approach and love for truth led me to the point where I couldn’t deny it anymore: the Catholic Church is home. My wife and I just started OCIA last week, and your work helped make that possible.
147
@cyprian_33 · 11 months ago
I used to mock the papacy when I was Eastern Orthodox now I’m happily Catholic. It’s possible to be wrong about things you’re convicted against lol: God has a unique way of humbling people.
180
@saml3959 · 11 months ago
Prot here, I'm so thankful for you, Gavin, and all of the other YouTubers that provide honest and clear discussions. You're such a great resource for helping me understand what my Catholic brother and sisters believe. May we all do better in following Christ day after day.
148
@DaveJohnson-d7i · 11 months ago
Good on you for showing the scripts to the people you're responding to. Appreciate the commitment to steelmanning over strawmanning
116
@PInk77W1 · 11 months ago
“I just know Jesus and the Church are one”<br>St Joan of Arc
7
@AlejandroLopez-oy2jn · 11 months ago
You know it's serious when Trent and Joe reply this video
164
@toddvoss52 · 11 months ago
I was glad that Trent briefly mentioned that Jesus on changed the name of Peter, not any of the other Apostles. In the bible it is significant when God gives someone a new name (Abraham). It means they will have a key role in the history of Salvation.
41
@DJ_Frankfurter · 11 months ago
The level of your writing and editing has hit a new height with this video! I'm so happy that your team is on the Catholic side.
35
@Freebird25x · 11 months ago
I hope all is well Mr. Horn 🫶🏽
45
Up next
A Case for Infant Baptism (Gavin Ortlund Response)
The Counsel of Trent · 87K views
25 Reasons Peter Was NOT The First Pope! (REBUTTED)
The Counsel of Trent · 141K views
The one Papacy question that STUMPS Protestants...
Shameless Popery · 120K views
Trent Horn Answers My Biggest Objections to Catholicism
Maybe God Podcast and The Counsel of Trent · 328K views
The Retrieval Podcast // Episode 2 // Reading Scripture with the Fathers
The Retrieval Podcast · 458 views
Where Is The Pope In The Bible? — EVERY Objection to the Papacy Answered!
Catholic Answers Live Clips · 49K views
When Did the Papacy Begin? (Response to Joe Heschmeyer)
Gavin Ortlund · 64K views
Michael Horton's Response to Me on Sola Scriptura (REBUTTED)
The Counsel of Trent · 108K views
Your Protestant Objections ANSWERED (Dr. John Bergsma) | Ep. 583
Matt Fradd and St. Paul Center · 246K views
REBUTTAL: "Why I Don't Accept The Papacy" (MEGA EPISODE)
Shameless Popery and The Catechumen · 80K views
Answering Redeemed Zoomer's "14 Catholic Contradictions"
The Counsel of Trent · 289K views
Did Jesus Really Rise From The Dead? A Historian vs Scholar Debate
Justin Brierley | Think Faith · 56K views
How I Was Stunned By Scripture | John Bergsma
St. Paul Center · 401K views
Are Bishops Biblical?
Shameless Popery · 45K views
The Papacy Is Not From God
Gavin Ortlund · 138K views
Chatting with an Ex-Catholic About Catholicism
The Counsel of Trent · 187K views
Debate: Did Jesus Rise From the Dead? - Trent Horn vs Alex O'Connor
Alex O'Connor · 765K views
Is the Book of Mormon Divinely Inspired? w/ @thoughtfulfaith2020 and @TheCounselofTrent
Matt Fradd · 348K views
My Response to Wes Huff's Case Against Catholicism
The Counsel of Trent · 213K views
The Truth, Reality, and Conspiracy Theories (Joe Heschmeyer) | Ep. 553
Matt Fradd · 129K views
Can Protestantism be Redeemed? (with Redeemed Zoomer)
The Counsel of Trent · 397K views
7 Verses Every Catholic Should Know | Dr. John Bergsma
St. Paul Center · 835K views
The One Passage that Proves the Papacy (to Protestants)
Shameless Popery · 286K views
Ask Me Anything, August 12, 2026 (LIVE FROM CATHOLIC ANSWERS STUDIO!)
Shameless Popery · 22K views
INTENSE Discussion on the Papacy (Cordial Catholic x Gospel Simplicity Crossover)
Gospel Simplicity · 110K views
Why I Don't Accept The Papacy
Gavin Ortlund · 171K views