The Most Infamous Arkham Knight "Review"
125K views · Dec 22, 2025 · Gaming
Comments · 969
@thatguyaqua · 9 months ago · pinned
If you harass or otherwise use this coverage as an excuse to needlessly hate on Mayo I consider you a massive LOSER
1K
@lambuffie · 9 months ago (edited)
I'll never forget his infamous Elden Ring "charity" stream to buy himself a PS5, where, in the stream, he was getting angry at his viewers trying to help him, and he was just essentially crapping on the game and not playing it properly. Keep in mind, he also said games should push you outside of your comfort zone and the game was doing exactly that.<br><br>Edit: I forgot to add that he didn't even buy the game, he literally had a viewer of his gift it to him for him to play it. There’s also a video of the stream on YT by Under the Ranklin Sean if anyone is curious about the stream.
1.9K
@panoskatrin99 · 9 months ago
I dont understand why a batman game being "batman porn" is bad... yea its batman game?
1.9K
@theicepickthatkilledtrotsk658 · 9 months ago
My main problem with Mayo is that he is one of those guys who has an ultra-narrow definition of what good game desings is. He views anything outside it as inherently bad and does not bother to learn it. He obviously heard that Arkham Knight is the ''bad one'' and did not give it a fair shake.
1K
@TheGreenManiac10 · 9 months ago
Bro says there's too much going on yet he Glazes Doom Eternal
1K
@Jojo-nq3bp · 9 months ago
<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sJcmgf4-_1Q&t=414">6:54</a> he likes doom eternal and that game glazes tf out of the doom slayer<br>it's not even close
1K
@Twobrosgamingsixfeetapart · 9 months ago
<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sJcmgf4-_1Q&t=296">4:56</a> with all due respect, his reputation is definitely his fault. Considering how much he loves to argue with every single little bit of criticism, he gets in his comments. He quite literally thinks that if you don't like him, you're wrong.
535
@SpikeJet2736 · 9 months ago
Doom Eternal was his lightning in a bottle. All his reviews since then have him looking like a chicken running without it's head
409
@Exclusivesadblues · 9 months ago
Under the Mayo’s criticism isn’t even the worse criticism I’ve ever heard from the guy. And I mean way before he ever posted his video.
250
@Beyond59 · 9 months ago
The one thing that bugged me about mayo s review is that he stated knight is objectively bad not just his opinions that’s a big part of him getting backlash
449
@steampunkburrito · 9 months ago
I think the backlash was warranted because of his tone he took in his video. The tone of his voice as well as his wording made him come off as disingenuous and that hes still responding to comments even the ones that provide criticism with defensiveness and sometimes out right insulting with a "I'm right your wrong" really rubs me the wrong way. I think the backlash should of been more intense. Also Mayos Elden Ring stream is pure pain. All he did was beg for money and refuse to engage in the game.
275
@venomtron · 9 months ago
Something that rubbed me the wrong way, wasnt really the criticism of the game itself but rather the smugness and arrogance in his voice. <br><br>You my Boy Aqua have also said things I dont agree with but you always measure your words and tone. Heck, even if it is a hot take or unpopular opinion it never comes off as "My opinion is fact, I know better than all of you".
324
Up next

Why Players hated Mary Jane
That Guy Aqua · 148K views

Everyone Told Me To Play... Batman: Arkham Asylum & Arkham City
Under The Mayo · 38K views

Arkham Origins Azrael DLC is Not Great
That Guy Aqua · 121K views

This Is One Of THE WORST Batman Arkham Knight Reviews
ColinsWrld · 666K views

Batman Arkham City: The Gang War - An Examination
Born To Rebel · 16K views

UnderTheMayo Is The Biggest Gaming Hypocrite
ShaunTheLegend · 66K views

We Don't Hate The Dark Knight System Enough - Batman: Arkham Origins
ClownPuncher139 · 339K views

Silent Hill Townfall Is So Boring It's TORTURE
Tryedz · 74K views

Why Batman Arkham Knight is Basically Perfect
NickynoBicky · 96K views

Arkham City's Women Problem
Micah Edmonds · 16K views

Why Modern Superheroes Suck - They Don't Fight Crime
Fantagonistic · 123K views

Breaking Down the Worst Batman Arkham Knight Review Ever - MattTGM
MattTGM · 94K views

Silent Hill F — I Think I Hate This Game...
Under The Mayo · 206K views

The Definitive Arkham Suit Ranking
SPACEBOYGIBSON · 59K views

“Trepang2 SUCKS because it’s DIFFERENT” Under The Mayo’s review is Ultrakill all over again
Batakanta · 149K views

5 Unanswered Questions In Batman: Arkham Asylum
ClownPuncher139 · 305K views

Debunking More Of The Batman Arkham Series' Biggest Myths...
Charles Cardy · 53K views

YouTube's Worst Reviewer | Under The Mayo Can't Stop Contradicting Himself (Mayo's Sifu review Pt 1)
Psychonautic Therapy · 215K views

What Batman Arkham Knight Suit is THE BEST?
That Guy Aqua · 50K views

UnderTheMayo Is The Worst Game Reviewer On Youtube
ShaunTheLegend · 335K views

Was Arkham Knight Really THAT Bad?
That Boy Aqua · 103K views

Arkham Origins — All Batman, No Car. ( REVIEW )
Under The Mayo · 38K views

Under The Mayo's Elden Ring Stream was a DUMPSTER FIRE...
ThunderStruck115 · 167K views

The ONLY Good Bane - Batman: Arkham Origins
ClownPuncher139 · 569K views

Top 5 Easiest & Hardest Arkham Bosses
ClownPuncher139 · 285K views

Can Arkham Batman Survive The ABSOLUTE Universe?
GothamPaladin · 213K views