MLP Fan Theories are DUMB

Comments · 1.2K

• SC

  @scribblecloud · 2 years ago

  i dont think scootaloo cant fly because she wasnt taught, you can see that her wings are physically smaller than other pegasi's as an adult too, she just seems to be born that way

  6.1K

• XT

  @Xtraaa444 · 2 years ago

  please no not the separated  at birth theory god no pinkie and cheese literally have a kid 😭😭

  3.5K

• CA

  @camrynbrewer2370 · 2 years ago

  It was confirmed that Pinkie Pie and Marble are fraternal twins, so that debunks the theory that Pinkie is adopted.

  2.3K

• ST

  @starrazors · 2 years ago

  tbh scottaloo being disabled makes more sense. im pretty sure her adult form has the same ungrown wings if youre desperate for hard proof. id love to see her as disability rep anyways, i struggle w/ walking and writing/drawing and its nice seeing people w/ similar struggles be treated like theyre people 💗💗

  1.3K

• JO

  @JoshucaVA · 2 years ago (edited)

  The Scootaloo parent theory I actually give a 0 considering that the timeskip at the end shows the size of her wings still being too small as an adult. There's also the fact she clearly spent large periods trying to fly growing up. She's physically disabled, likely from birth, considering something like strength, which is implied in the theory, can be treated through therapy.

  1K

• TR

  @TrixieEnjoyer · 2 years ago

  if the dragon egg test was actually meant to be completed, wouldnt every student have their own dragon?

  922

• FL

  @FlamerElBossoGangsteritoChito · 2 years ago

  thats not a theory, but a small notice. if you looks ta the mane six, half of them represent stereotypical concept of their own race: AJ is an earthpony farmer, Rainbow Dash is a pegasus who manages the clouds, weather, and overall loves flying like any pegasus, and Twilight is a gifted unicorn, whos only job she does is magic. How ever, on the other hand we see Pinkie, who was previously a typical worker on a rock farm, but then become a pastry-cooker, thus breaking the stereotype, Fluttershy is not a typical pegasus who loves speed and stuff and more down to earth, and Rarity uses her magic only as her third hand or something, just to hold things while she makes her dresses.

  698

• TO

  @Toonstation47 · 2 years ago (edited)

  “3d shunks isn’t real,he can’t hurt you”<br>3d shunks:

  1.2K

• LU

  @lunatic_pigeon · 2 years ago

  I always imagine Pinkie Pie is a copy of her grandma, or very similar to her. In the first or second episode Pinkie sings the Giggle at the ghostly(?) song and she says it was her grandma that taught her to laugh in the face of fear. Pinkie&apos;s family doesn&apos;t laugh nor say stuff like that, so I imagine her granny was just like her and she took a lot from her and that&apos;s also why her family tolerates a lot of her shenanigans despite being annoyed - Because she&apos;d remind them of their grandma and they&apos;d love her even more because of that nostalgia.

  222

• RA

  @RaccoonRevolution · 2 years ago

  My guess would be that Applejack&apos;s first hat was her dad&apos;s, but it started to get messed up with time. So, being the pragmatic one, she stopped wearing it. But of course, no new hat is ever going to fit quite the same or feel quite right. So you KNOW she spent the rest of her life buying similar hats, trying to chase that perfect fit. And that&apos;s how she ended up with that many hats.<br><br>No, YOU&apos;RE projecting my favorite hoodie onto this. 😤

  179

• TE

  @Teruskaroblox · 1 year ago

  <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n4G5qn-xae8&amp;t=536">8:56</a> It was literally day😭 she just sleeps during the day and she’s probably a heavy sleeper and really tired from walking in dreams all night

  79

• NA

  @namelessnavnls8060 · 2 years ago (edited)

  The &quot;Pinkie has magic&quot; theory is actually backed up by when everypony gets their magic back in School Raze II, a little spark of pink magic goes straight to Pinkie. And before anyone says &quot;WELL earth ponies have magic too!&quot;, AJ received no such spark in the same scene.<br>Also I&apos;m pretty sure Scootaloo is just meant to have a disability rather than be.. neglected/undertaught.<br>I think she&apos;s meant to be a representation for kids and adults with disabilities to relate to.

  385