Every Song in Thomas’ Railway Showdown Re-Fired Up Ranked Worst to Best

Comments · 64

• BE

  @benjamin_0265 · 2 days ago (edited)

  Apart from Fish and Four Heads being as low as they are (I think they should&apos;ve been ranked higher than Ghost Train at the very least), I can get behind a lot of these takes, ESPECIALLY Boiler Test being number 1.<br><br><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j0devC6TfmY&amp;t=382">6:22</a> Also during this part, Thovis says:<br>&quot;I could wear the trousers on this island, I could be the greatest engine of all!&quot; which given the context of the original YTP, makes perfect sense.

  3

• DU

  @duncan_potter2860 · 2 days ago (edited)

  I&apos;m a bit late to this video and I missed the premiere, so I dunno if this comment will be seen, but I wanted to say two things:<br>1) As much as I dislike the overused Sonic drowning motif, I think the drowning motif is strangely fitting to give to Percy of all engines. There was both a book &amp; Thomas episode called &quot;Percy Takes the Plunge,&quot; which was basically Percy having an accident of plunging into the water. I know that Percy isn&apos;t the only engine to have a water-related accident, but regardless if it was intentional or not, the fact that the drowning motif was given to Percy, an engine that has an entire book/episode dedicated to him falling into the water, is honestly kind of clever.<br>2) I actually have a very minor gripe about Splendid Somberness, though it&apos;s not about the song itself. In the original mod, after James goes insane, his icons on the HP bar were references to actual faces that James made in the show, which was a really neat detail, but in Re-Fired Up, they completely ditched that for some reason.<br><br>Feel free to disagree with me on this. Everyone has their own opinions.

  1

• BR

  @Brantfictionfan · 2 days ago

  this mod has one of my favourite osts of any mod, it&apos;s so fun and charming and some songs go really hard. Asboi being that high was a nice suprise because I love Asboi Re-fired (because Thomas the Chav Engine is a joke between me and my friend and the song is just really good)

  1

• OL

  @OliverBibey-h4f · 2 days ago

  I wasn’t expecting Boiler Test to beat out Fallout

  2

• NU

  @Numberonefishmanfan · 2 days ago

  Since you somehow didn’t notice the silly billy reference in splendid somberness, it’s starts around <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j0devC6TfmY&amp;t=1581">26:21</a>

• BL

  @blazingdragonsyt9647 · 2 days ago

  Wow, this has been an AMAZING premiere to listen to while I was playing something else, and I honestly agree with most of the ranking! Though (and this is just a small opinion of mine), I would boost the HELL out of Ghost Train&apos;s ranking in my own ranking, as well as dropping Fallout a lot lower (The song is in a... semitone? I think it&apos;s what it&apos;s called? That I personally hate, compared to the original), and a few minor adjustments. But, I DEFINITELY love that Boiler Test ended up in 1st because of how well it was executed!<br>Also, small nitpick in <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j0devC6TfmY&amp;t=3343">55:43</a> , the person speaking doesn&apos;t say &apos;Put out the fire!&apos; He actually says, &apos;Drop the fire! Drop the fire!&apos; I know people normally can&apos;t make it out, which is why it&apos;s a small nitpick instead of a big deal, but just thought I&apos;d mention it-

  2

• AS

  @Asael20YT · 1 day ago

  The reason why percy is in Always-watches and then later on Lose all hope is because the percy who&apos;s with the spooky kids is specifically the percy from the original ghost train animation. As for the one in lose all hope, that&apos;s (how i see it) a different percy, specifically the one from the analog horror where it comes from<br><br>So this means there&apos;s two percys, or after the ghost train encounter, percy just dies and then turns into the other one

• LE

  @LeftStickGaming240 · 2 days ago

  P E A K<br>I was NOT expecting Boiler Test to take first place, and I ESPECIALLY wasnt expecting u to be as harsh as u were to the new Fallout (u werent too harsh but still). Ghost Train is still under-rated lol<br>@Neos-Studio Can I recommend a mod(s) for u to make a video on? The mod(s) is called Pluto&apos;s Reprisal. I&apos;d love to hear ur thoughts on it&apos;s OST :)

  3

• JU

  @justsem1368 · 2 days ago

  honestly, the perfect version of Fallout (in my eyes) would be having the additional part that Re-Fired add play right after Toad&apos;s and BF&apos;s section, with Toad and BF either switching who sings and who not or Toad being lead with BF in a back as they sing against Beast, basically lean into &quot;what if there still something left from Oliver in this monster&quot;, and only when have Toad being killed by Beast (and way shorter when in Re-Fired) and transition into &quot;All I Want&quot; part because i think it just killed the pace of whole ending for no reason and have it take place before pop-up would be better when other way.<br><br>But that just my opinion + i&apos;m not a composer, but still thought to leave my thoughts for discussion. Peak video btw, glad Boiler Test won this time

  3

• BL

  @Blackjack-s9g · 2 days ago

  Me: <b>sees Fish in C Tier</b> Damnit. I was really hoping it could get into at least B Tier.

  1

• TH

  @thesonicfan2176 · 2 days ago

  I usually listen to number 1 with the pitch lowered by 2 semitones , it sounds so cool that way

  2

• IT

  @Itishe-nm8lm · 2 days ago

  I&apos;m back to rank YAYYYYYYYY<br><br>This mod is very good! Even hot potato and fish are only C tier lol<br><br>16 - Hot Potato (Hey at least it ain&apos;t X)<br>15 - Fish (I just don&apos;t really like it)<br>14 - Four Heads (W for using Mommy Mearest but that&apos;s about it)<br>13 - Always Watches (MASSIVE step above it&apos;s old counterpart)<br>12 -Termination (It&apos;s good I like it)<br>11 - Great Destinations (Nothing bad about it I just like the other 10 more)<br>10 - Ghost Train (I am a big stupid baby who likes Hide And Seek from Rerun unironically ofc I was gonna like this)<br>9 -Oopsies! (Silly and fun)<br>8 -Cutters Torch (Love how desolate and hopeless it feels)<br>7 - Asboi - (Genuinely got a good laugh out of me the first time)<br>6 - Lose All Hope (Percy should NOT sound that good but he does)<br>5 - Really Useful (An F or D tier song into an A or S tier one, Impressive)<br>4 - Boiler Test (Take everything good about the og, and make it better while removing the bad)<br>3 - Number One (Same reasoning for Boiler Test)<br>2 - FALLOUT (The new melodies at the end hit hard but I feel like this just doesn&apos;t hit the same as the og, still S tier song tho)<br>1 - Splendid Somberness (Genuinely a top 20 fnf song.)

  1