Did Vatican II Teach Error?

Comments · 1.2K

• PO

  @povilzem · 2 months ago

  It's funny how Winger thinks "separated brethren" doesn't in itself include excommunication and anathema.

  176

• FC

  @fcatulo · 2 months ago

  Now that is a beauty of a shirt

  342

• BR

  @bradyhayes7911 · 2 months ago

  Hey Joe! Was really great seeing you speak this past week at St. Bart's. We actually were able to bring my Protestant birth mother and her husband, and they found the Pope Peter talk very compelling. Thanks for the work you do!

  140

• NY

  @nycbaby2307 · 2 months ago

  <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cclRzy7daxc">0:00</a> Collegiality<br><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cclRzy7daxc&amp;t=1096">18:16</a> Ecumenism<br><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cclRzy7daxc&amp;t=1848">30:48</a> &nbsp;Religious Liberty

  30

• JA

  @JasonGPlus · 2 months ago

  This is the first time this pun has occurred to me, but have you ever considered selling Shameless Potpourri?

  61

• CO

  @ConservativeCorner1776 · 2 months ago

  Another great video from our boy Joey Hesch

  19

• JO

  @JohnDeRosa1990 · 2 months ago (edited)

  Outstanding video, Joe. I hope this can help some SSPX members overcome their intellectual objections to Vatican 2. Their objections are not groundless or without merit. They have some real basis. Yet, they are not insurmountable. As you show, when the proper distinctions are made, Vatican 2 is orthodox and does not constitute rupture with prior teaching. Dunningan&apos;s work really helped me on the Religious Liberty Objection, and I hope it continues to get more attention.

  80

• JO

  @jonathanabuthan1373 · 2 months ago

  let us pray for the blessings of the Almighty upon His Church and Her hierarchy, with and under Peter

  16

• AD

  @aDirtyLeg · 2 months ago (edited)

  YouTube hid this from me for 38 SECONDS. Also, Joe, that’s a heck of a shirt

  126

• MA

  @madmachio · 2 months ago

  Thank you for this!! Keep it up

  15

• SA

  @sarasalazar7538 · 2 months ago

  A lot of people in this comment section seem to keep forgetting that there&apos;s a difference between heresy and schism. The SSPX (as far as I know) has not formally promulgated any heresy, but that Does Not mean that they couldn&apos;t possibly be in schism. There&apos;s two separate words for two separate sins for a reason. And as Joe put in his book, Pope Peter, the promise Christ made to His Church means that we will never have to choose between heresy and schism.

  76

• VA

  @vastbubble · 2 months ago (edited)

  Keen to watch! One request I had Joe was to ask if you can do a deep dive on Redeemer Zoomers views on schism and why the Reformation was a justified breakaway. From what I gather he thinks schism is never justified for heresy unless the Church expells you, and he claims that&apos;s what happened in the Reformation. <br><br>I think a deep breakdown would be very helpful for many people. God bless!

  38