Every Treasure Island Adaptation RANKED

Comments · 230

• LI

  @lillith3159 · 5 years ago

  Its kinda ironic that Orson´s Silver was always drunk during the filming when Silver was probably the only pirate in the island that refused to get drunk until the job was done

  131

• SH

  @shinypiece6984 · 5 years ago

  Glad to see Treasure Planet ranked high; it's grown to be one of my favorite Disney movies.

  103

• MO

  @moonlordgaming4537 · 4 years ago

  1988 Soviet treasure island has the biggest chad and the greatest fight scene in all of the treasure island franchise.come now? Number 7 is definitely an insult😂🤣.now I can understand it if it’s in the top 2 but 7 is pretty low lol

  24

• CA

  @catconte6919 · 5 years ago

  I absolutely love muppet treasure island, the muppet humor comes through beautiful and winds through the story without completely overwhelming it. That's helped by casting Jim and Silver as humans. And Tim Curry absolutely steals the show, plus Profesional Pirate slaps!

  68

• SP

  @spensatron · 4 years ago

  My dad was the DP for the 1990 version.  As a family we lived in London for a month followed by 2 months in Jamaica.  Charleston Heston was a class act!  While in England he took us to see the HMS Victory.  I was about 5 years old and he would carry me on his shoulders through the train station.  During that time he would boom ‘stop the train!!’ in his epic Charlton Heston voice.  Obviously I had no idea of the reference until I looked to up now(greatest show on earth), but I thought it sounded cool, so from on top his shoulders I would feed him lines of different vehicle choices that should also stop, like a taxi or a double decker, in which he dutifully delivered my revisions. It was a fun game that I never got tired of and neither did he.  Either that or he was a really good actor!  Great times!! RIP Chuck!

  45

• AB

  @AbbaZaba00 · 3 years ago

  Dude the kid from the 1934 version looked like he was told to act like Shirley Temple

  7

• AL

  @AlfredFJones1776 · 4 years ago

  Treasure Island 1950 is my favorite because of Robert Newton. I love him so much.

  19

• RE

  @rektnation6986 · 5 years ago

  When you played “I’m still here”, I instinctively started head banging and singing. This song rocks!! One of my all time favorite movies!!

  32

• WI

  @willfrench3693 · 4 years ago

  I can't say I've seen all the adaptations but the 1990 version is one of my favourite films and I'm not surprised it came in at number 1, fantastic film and soundtrack too

  18

• DR

  @dreamlandnightmare · 3 years ago

  Absolutely, the 1990 version isn't only the best adaptation of Treasure Island, it's the best pirate movie of all time.

  33

• VI

  @vibeke793 · 4 years ago

  I was getting worried when we were down to 3 left and the Charleton Heston one hadn't come up yet! Absolutely agree with your picks, man!

  32

• KA

  @KadenzaKat98 · 4 years ago

  Ngl, I legit shouted YES out loud when I heard your #1 ranking! That's my all time favorite adaptation of Treasure Island since I was just a kid, with Muppet Treasure Island and Treasure Planet being close seconds! I've been telling people that the 1990 version is the best for years, and I highly recommend it to anyone who loves the book just as much!!

  34