REACTING to Eagles - I Can't Tell You Why
39K views · Apr 14, 2026 · Music
Comments · 149
@JohnWJ3rd · 5 months ago
Elegant is a very good word to describe this song. I've been listening to Eagles all of my life and among all of their amazing catalog, this is still my favorite. It's perfect.
45
@hopeklemann1 · 5 months ago
🌸 this is my favorite Eagles' song
43
@PjRjHj · 5 months ago
One of the greatest slow solos
22
@PreblePratt · 3 months ago
I saw the Eagles in concert 3 times. Best band in history.
6
@waynehauser3611 · 5 months ago
Yessss The Eagles are really that good .
14
@kellywaite3706 · 11 days ago
Very Smooth that is what I would describe this song as
@dimestorephilosopher3308 · 5 months ago
A band where the bass player is like #4 on their singer list and he has a banger.
7
@bigdaddyeb56 · 5 months ago
Beautiful Song for a Very Beautiful Lady !! Thank You Steph
18
@shawn1432 · 5 months ago
I’m 72 and yes I had the same feelings you have when I discovered the Eagles back in 70’s, I got to see them live in 75 in Santa Barbra Cal, they will become DNA !!
14
@REN..X12 · 11 days ago
Eagles are Legend <br>💛 the react
@edwincancelii2917 · 5 months ago (edited)
Timothy is an awesome natural tenor. U.S.A. 🇺🇸 loves ❤️ you. I’m glad you love ❤️ that soft rock 🎸 song. 🎧 Right on. 👍
8
@indaleciomendez8442 · 1 month ago (edited)
I was 8 years of age, when this song came out, but I remember listening to this song as a kid and going in to my teens, so you can imagine all the best songs from late 70s and through out the 80s were my era, this is pure nostalgia for me, and to see today's generation listening to what we got to experience when they first came out, is pure excitement, which i could stay in the 80s. Now you need to react to Baby Come Back by the band Player. It's just as good as this song.
Up next
FIRST TIME REACTING to Eagles - Take It to the Limit
Steph Gard · 56K views
Mom and Daughter Get SWOONED by Eagles - I Can't Tell You Why
Natural Born Reactors · 120K views
Eagles - I Can't Tell You Why (Official Video) | WE DID NOT EXPECT THAT VOICE... OMG | First Listen
Cliff Beats Classics · 218K views
Bessent PANICS As Bond CRISIS Hits WORST MOMENT - Dutch Say BACK OFF USA
House of El · 168K views
Procol Harum A Whiter Shade of Pale Reaction 😮 This Sounds Absolutely Timeless
Abigirl Reacts · 34K views
FIRST TIME REACTING to The Cure Just Like Heaven
Steph Gard · 19K views
I CANT TELL YOU WHY - EAGLES | FIRST TIME HEARING *REACTION VIDEO* 😭🔥
Lizzie the Gangster Hippie · 240K views
REACTING to Michael Jackson - Smooth Criminal
Steph Gard · 58K views
The Eagles' Softest Hit Had Me in My FEELS | "I Can't Tell You Why"
Renée-Suzanne · 13K views
"Wild Horses" by The Rolling Stones Made me Cry
Erica Reacts - Music & Retro Gaming · 132K views
Eagles - I Can't Tell You Why | FIRST TIME REACTION
ARES Media · 90K views
FIRST TIME REACTING to Eagles - Hotel California (Live 1977)
Steph Gard · 89K views
HOW IS THIS SO SMOOTH?! 😳 Eagles – I Can’t Tell You Why | Soft Rock Reaction
BARS & BARBELLS · 51K views
EAGLES-ONE OF THESE NIGHTS | FIRST TIME REACTION
Bisscute · 50K views
I Was Very Wrong! First Time Ever Reacting to The Eagles - Hotel California
Rosalie Elliott · 150K views
Why Don’t Love Songs Sound Like This Anymore? | Kenny Rogers - Lady
Finnish Girl Reacts Music · 326K views
🤩 *I CAN TELL YOU WHY* by Eagles FIRST TIME REACTION!
Sing with Emma today · 314K views
Spanish Girl Reacts to Eagles - One of These Nights (Live 1977)
Spanish Girl Reacts · 23K views
FIRST TIME listening to GEORGE MICHAEL "Careless Whisper" REACTION
Lilly Jane Reacts · 338K views
Musicians REACT to The Graystones: I Can't Tell You Why (Eagles cover, 2025)
Glenn and Adrian's Rock Talk · 263K views
I FROZE... HAD TO REPLAY THIS IMMEDIATELY!! I Righteous Brothers - Unchained Melody (reaction)
The Crib Reacts · 312K views
What An INCREDIBLE PERFORMANCE! First Reaction to Eagles - One of These Nights (Live 1977)
Natural Born Reactors · 69K views
ARE YOU KIDDING ME!? First Time Reaction to Eagles - "Hotel California"
StaceyRPG · 314K views
Eagles The Best of My Love 1977 | First Time Hearing This Live Performance
Bisscute · 44K views
My First Time Hearing "Lyin' Eyes" by The Eagles, And I'm Mystified!
The Charismatic Voice · 377K views
I EXPOSED my Daughter to Eagles - Hotel California
Natural Born Reactors · 358K views