Ads skipped

Barney and Robin's First Relationship: Why it Worked and Why it Didn’t

43K views · Sep 4, 2025 · Film & Animation

Comments · 18

  • @carinelaberge5352 · 2 months ago

    Love your take. They're one of my all time favorite storylines on TV . The chemistry, the complexity, the growth. It was too well written to screw up withing 5 minutes. The finale does not exist 😂

    58

  • @KashyaCharsi · 1 month ago

    The difference between playing house and finding a dynamic that actually works for them.

    11

  • @Suzanna.Margarjan · 2 months ago

    In my mind Barney and Robin are still married

    19

  • @SM-th7pw · 2 months ago

    <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JxzSy7EgZrQ&amp;t=369">6:09</a> Barney founded 67 😱

    12

  • @OrianaAlejandraBetancourt · 2 months ago

    I was washing the dishes while listening to this. So for a solid minute I was like &quot;who is Bonnie?&quot;

    15

  • @loganmanuel5915 · 3 weeks ago

    Thank you for breaking down this series. Your takes are very underrated, and so is your content. Please do some more, with whatever movies, TV shows, or any other sort of media you find interesting!

  • @Sharzz1612 · 2 months ago

    This take is spot on, I always had a problem with the way the writers handled their relationship in season 5. I still feel like they prematurely had to break them up but I feel like they should have kept them together and have them grow more. Now knowing why they did what they did to them in the end is why I think that they should have tried to fix their relationship much sooner and not spent so much time on filler relationships. However, they needed to grow separately to realize their past mistake in this season. Barney and Robin BOTH had that character development so strong nothing could break them up. By the end they had the most secure and happy relationship.

    2

  • @williamnathanael412 · 2 months ago

    This should have more views!

    10

  • @MeghamDraws · 2 weeks ago

    You’re doing Gods work

  • @tuneflake8433 · 2 months ago

    Great video! Best I&apos;ve seen on their relationship I think 😲<br>Plus, love the Persona music 🥰

    5

  • @Theodore_ML · 2 months ago

    Finally, &nbsp;someone who noticed that the hints of them having feelings for each other in Season 1😅 &nbsp;<br>Actually the HAVE YOU MET TED is where Barney starts developing feelings for her, when he noticed her talk as she was introduced to the gang and Lilly interrupted Barney&apos;s trainof thought when Robin went to the loo &amp; she asked Ted &amp; Barney that she likes Robin &amp; wants her to be part of the gang and none of them should sleep with her, and put emphasis on Barney

  • @prollotov · 2 months ago (edited)

    great video again. would love to see more 💜

    1

Up next

LIVE

The REAL Reason Barney's Ending Was Perfect

The Blue Horn · 52K views

LIVE

Why How I Met Your Mother’s Pilot is Perfect

Jake with a B · 150K views

LIVE

Why Chase Became House Instead of Foreman

Mr Gregory and 2 more · 199K views

LIVE

Ted's Wrong Relationships

Pensive Whiskers · 168K views

LIVE

The Underlying Misogyny of Grand Romantic Gestures

The Soak · 1.4M views

LIVE

Every Time Marshall Was a Good Friend

Edgar On Comedy · 15K views

LIVE

Shauna Fumbling Every Eligible Man in Pawnee | Parks and Recreation

Parks and Recreation · 403K views

LIVE

Love Is Blind Netherlands Has Arrived & It Starts Off In A SHOCKING Way - Episodes 1 to 5 RECAP

Bachelor Fantake · 153K views

LIVE

The Grief and Pain of How I Met Your Mother - Video Essay

Jake with a B · 144K views

LIVE

How to (NOT) Make Hockey Hot - Heated Rivalry VS Off Campus

The Writer's Block · 184K views

LIVE

The Best Episode of How I Met Your Mother

Jake with a B · 17K views

LIVE

Every Time Barney Was a Good Friend!

Edgar On Comedy · 134K views

LIVE

How Barney’s Job ACTUALLY Worked

The Blue Horn · 312K views

LIVE

when an episode isn't like the rest of the show

Paul Platt · 1.3M views

LIVE

Why Robin and Barney Went Wrong - How I Met Your Mother

The Take · 793K views

LIVE

The "broke" Character That Isn't Really Broke

Scripted Chemistry · 583K views

LIVE

An Underrated Friendship on HIMYM

Pensive Whiskers · 95K views

LIVE

How Misogyny Ruined Sitcoms

The Soak · 937K views

LIVE

Every Time Ted Deserved To Be Dumped!

Edgar On Comedy and Sitcom Science · 320K views

LIVE

lily & barney being a comedic duo for fourteen minutes straight

schrbctsky · 1.6M views

LIVE

Josh Radnor talks How I Met Your Mother, making peace with Ted Mosby & the pressures of fame (4K)

Half the Picture · 295K views

LIVE

Best vs Worst Teds Love Choices HIMYM

Edgar On Comedy · 282K views

LIVE

Every HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER Theory That Might Actually Be True Explained in 19 Minutes

movies explained · 229K views

LIVE

How I Met Your Mother: The Truth About Robin, The Mother & Lily | Compilation

The Take · 182K views

LIVE

The Ones That Make You Laugh: Part 4 | Friends

Friends · 471K views

LIVE

Why Marshall Settled for Lily | How I Met Your Mother

OlurinattiPOP! · 565K views

YouTube, with the door locked.

Aegis plays a clean stream instead of YouTube's player, so pre-roll ads, trackers, and fingerprinting never ride along. Drop Shields any time if you want the official player back.