Ranking Killers by Whether Patrick Jane Could Catch Them
1.2M views · Aug 29, 2026 · Entertainment
Comments · 270
@MovieCriticsClub · 1 month ago · pinned
What characters would you want to see for a PART 3? Join the DISCORD: <a href="https://discord.gg/4Q7fV9RdAu">https://discord.gg/4Q7fV9RdAu</a>
28
@dreadybombom · 3 weeks ago
I swear The Mentalist didn't exist a year ago but now he's everywhere
599
@bigmansanister8716 · 2 weeks ago
Finally someone that doesnt down play Light Yagami. And first time seeing an accurate tier list, 10/10 video man
116
@white0wlz1 · 1 month ago (edited)
I think the main weaknes for Patrick is him not being a fighter , he is smart enough to catch people but when he faces real threat or anything related to physical attacks he would loose. So for breaking bad ,light and possibally the guy from scream(It would be clumsy but he canposibally kill ) . If they decide to physical attack he can't really do anything.Idk the guy from fall so I didn't mention him .
446
@l.pricetag.5207 · 1 month ago
Something to consider with the Trinity case is that Arthur seems to panic when it looks like the authorities are getting close. We see this when he notices Lundy that he starts worrying, which is something Lundy notices. I think if Lundy noticed, Patrick definitely will as it's his specialty. But he'd need to get close enough in the first place.<br><br>I actually agree with every placement here, at least the ones I know about haha.
308
@trempton4106 · 10 days ago
Another Issue for Jane against light would be that Jane definitely doesn't believe in Ghosts and other Spooky stuff which is exactly what happened in Death Note.
32
@mattibello05 · 1 month ago
I agree with everyone, given the fact that he probably would understand (except for Johan) that each one of these is who they’re looking for as soon as he interacts with them. They’ve shown to be pretty obvious to the trained eye.
126
@elmousse007 · 3 days ago
The problem with Jane is once you are a suspect, you are just done. He’ll know you are the culprit
2
@science-j8q · 4 weeks ago
But like i mean if misa didn't just randomly kind of tell L that shinigami exists L wouldn't have enough information to tell near and near wouldn't catch light
41
@AnonymousAnonymoE · 1 month ago
My thing with trinity, is that when the cbi finds out he's a serial killer, and they figure out his ritual, they would probably look around for deaths similar to the killings from before they started. Once they figure out about the family, I think they could then easily put a name to the killer
9
@owentravis2220 · 2 weeks ago
I started watching this show with my mom a year or two ago. When I found out this year it was trending on the internet, I was kind of shocked. I loved the show so much and we finished it a few nights ago. I've also watched MONSTER(the anime) and honestly, I have no idea how Patrick would catch Johan Liebert. Liebert might be the hardest one to catch. MONSTER was a great anime
14
@JFlame-l8v · 4 weeks ago
I would recommend Patrick Jane vs Johan Liebert as a seperate video!
44
Up next

Could Patrick Jane Catch These Serial Killers?
Movie Critics Club · 336K views

The 7 Levels of Intelligence in TV Explained
dnadz · 470K views

why this better call saul scene was so brilliant (Analysis)
Plot Demon · 199K views

Which Horror Villains Could Survive The Ultimate Predator?
Movie Critics Club · 47K views

How Long Would It Take Patrick Jane To Catch Light Yagami?
Cases Uncovered · 8.7K views

What Oogway Understands That Nobody Else Does
Recall This · 202K views

Ranking Killers by L's Chances of Catching Them
Movie Critics Club · 1.4M views

How The Mentalist Ruined Red John In A Single Episode
MentalistTime and DexterTime · 117K views

How Magnus Carlsen Silenced Everyone in One Tournament…
The Checkmate Corner · 1.8M views

The ENTIRE Red John Saga Explained
The Mentalist Central · 547K views

Yeah. This is the most Underrated Performance in TV
Epic Sell · 1M views

Every Jason Voorhees Ranked from Weakest to Strongest
Movie Critics Club · 114K views

Light Yagami Was Never Smart—Every Dumb Mistake in Death Note (Complete KIRA vs L Story)
Anime Balls Deep · 2.2M views

How Long Would It Take Dr. House To Catch Dexter?
Frenzaro · 616K views

How Did Red John Know About Jane's List?
The Mentalist Central · 217K views

Ranking Killers By Their Chances of Surviving Jack Reacher
Movie Critics Club · 927K views

When "The Strongest" Lives Up To Their Title
Pavelover · 1.6M views

Most Genius Patrick Jane Edits for 12 minutes and 39 seconds
Ranking Things · 338K views

The Mentalist being a comedy show for 10 minutes straight
nay_vids · 1.6M views

Could L Outsmart Jigsaw?
Specular Verse and 4 more · 75K views

What IF a LANTERN Wielded Every Power Ring At Once?
Comicfy · 433K views

How They Found Every Serial Killer...
Joe Bartolozzi · 5.9M views

The SMARTEST Traps In The Mentalist
The Mentalist Central · 393K views

Why Light vs L Isn't Close
Avent · 1M views

Which Horror Villains Could Survive The Punisher?
Movie Critics Club · 304K views

EVERY Time Dexter Got INSANELY LUCKY
DexterTime · 597K views