Was Hogwarts Legacy Really That Good?
544K views · Jun 30, 2026 · Gaming
Comments · 1.1K
@NextGameUp_ · 2 months ago · pinned
I’m currently beta testing FinalSave, a gaming backlog tracker I’ve been building.<br>Beta access: <a href="https://finalsave.app/">https://finalsave.app</a><br><br>It’s very early, so there may be bugs, missing features, and things that change over time. But if you’re someone who likes tracking what you’re playing, what you’ve finished, and what’s still sitting in the backlog, I’d love for you to try it and send feedback.<br>Steam works best right now. Console/platform integrations are still in progress.
29
@QuackenInsanity · 2 months ago
They were so close to making this the perfect Harry Potter game, and that's what's frustrating. You have this incredible school ready to go, but it doesn't feel like you're actually a student there; it's more like you're a tourist. There's no classes you have to go to, you can wander the castle freely at night, you can use unforgivable curses in the hallways without consequence, you can fly halfway across the country to go explore a cript or murder hundreds of poachers and no one will even notice to you're gone, etc. There's no Quidditch, no holiday events, no dances or romance, no chess or exploding snap, no famous witch and wizard cards to collect, no secret bathroom store to buy dungbombs at. It nails the darkness and mystery of the series really well, but it struggles to capture whimsy and adventure of living in a magic castle.
3.3K
@FreekBergen · 2 months ago
The side quest with Sebastian was way more fun then the main story plot
832
@MisterReginald141 · 2 months ago (edited)
This game would have benefited so much from dlc missions/spells and a proper NPC system in the castle. Being able to attack students, get chased by teachers and Prefects and then go to detention or escape would have made the world feel way more alive. Instead all the students are shadow ghosts basically the same code as the butterflies
1.2K
@ThePotchili · 3 months ago
Gameplay was on the weaker side but the world building is what made the game such a phenomenal experience for me. Exploring Hogwarts and Hogsmeade alone felt magical at first.
760
@TarnishedGamer-u6k · 2 months ago
This is why I don't regret getting the game on PC. These are some mods, to name a few that I've used in my playthroughs:<br><br>1. House Point System - adds house points to the game along with the hourglasses changing in real time to reflect them. It also gives homework and its own house cup system.<br>2. Immersive Modpack - gives all NPCs schedules. students attend class, go to hogsmeade in the weekend, go to common rooms in the evening, attend meals in the great hall, etc.<br>3. Night Curfew - Implements a curfew system to Hogwarts. Prefects will patrol the castle grounds between 11:45PM - 6:15AM. If you're caught you'll face the consequences.<br>4. Azkaban - If anyone sees you use unforgivables, the ministry will immediately be notified and send aurors after you to lock you up in Azkaban.<br>5. Emote with any NPC - Restore all station social actions available in game (sit in chair, eat, chat with npc and many more).<br>6. Spells Enhanced - 20 new spells found in the books and movies that werent originally in the game.<br>7. Spells & Talents - 9 new spells and 29 new talent points. You can also create inferi or even horcruxes.<br>8. Expecto Patronum - Add a new quest to obtain the spell with full voice acting and cutscenes.<br>9. Floo Companions - Summon classmates, npcs or even teachers using the new floo flame system and have them fight alongside you.<br>10. The Chamber of Secrets - Add a new quest to open the chamber. As of writing this the mod is fairly new so be on the lookout for updates.<br><br>and that's just a fraction of what the modding community has done in the game for the past 3 years. Go see for yourself.
491
@Jichael-c4r · 2 months ago
3 years?! Omg how is it that old already
252
@DrJones0801 · 2 months ago
I wish they removed half of the open world map and focused more on the actual Hogwarts castle, the forbidden forest, and Hogsmeade. I loved exploring the castle, but it felt like the game itself was trying its hardest to get you to leave.
110
@THISISLolesh · 2 months ago
The world was absolutely top tier, not even a big potter fan but Hogwarts was genuinely amazing to me when i explored it.
121
@datboimew · 2 months ago
I'm convinced that the broom flight in this game is the peak of flight in gaming. No Quidditch off the back of that mechanic was a collosal fail.
99
@paddyknapp4151 · 2 months ago
I liked playing my character as an uncaring sociopath, who, fortunate for the wizarding world, is pointed in the direction of their enemies
88
@ladypool1404 · 2 months ago
I played the game. I like the music, combat system and exploration BUT it's missing a few things. <br><br>- The patronus spell. We could choose between a cat, dog, eagle, lion, badger, snake, deer or fox. Fighting dementors sounds fun! <br>- A moral system. If we help others and saved creatures, the students will talke about us and the teachers will thank us but if we're cruel; everyone will be scared. We oculd be send to detention or in Askaban. <br>- Sitting or sleeping. Everyone can do that but not us... that's weird! <br>- Creating a pet like we create our avatar. The animal can find rare objets or help us fight enemies. He can also sleep with us, have a little bed. <br>- More classes. We had 3 or 4 if i remember (the potion, the botany, the basic spells) Not enough to make us part of the school. <br><br>If all this is in the next game, that would be cool 😄
105
Up next

Everything Wrong (and right) with Hogwarts Legacy
Thy Snake · 155K views

5 MASSIVE Plot Holes in EVERY Harry Potter Book (MEGA COMPILATION)
Harry Potter Theory · 219K views

Hogwarts Legacy's Storyline Explained... (Hogwarts Legacy Story Summary Explained)
Wizzo · 230K views

21 Upcoming Games In 2027 That Will Wreck Your Backlog
B O Z U S E · 891K views

A Deep Dive into Potterheads
Kurtis Conner · 11M views

Why Starfield is Genuinely An Unacceptable Game
AVV Gaming · 777K views

Harry Potter: Why Do We Need a Reboot? A Full Series Review - Part 1
The Thrifty Typewriter · 463K views

Cyberpunk’s Prison is Worse Than Death
nvRanger & Co. · 1.4M views

Tom Riddle's Complete Timeline: From Orphan to Dark Lord
Brett's Thoughts · 208K views

Minecraft, But There's Command Block Ores...
Wisp · 96K views

ESSENTIAL Tips I Wish I Knew Sooner 🪄 Hogwarts Legacy
Arktix · 5M views

I Played and Ranked EVERY Harry Potter Game
Orrnery · 583K views

The Complete Case Against Harry Potter
Josh Everton · 361K views

Hogwarts Legacy Prologue Rewrite
Edel Arewyn · 209 views

I BINGED Every HARRY POTTER Movie For The FIRST TIME - Full Series Retrospective & Critique
Movie Overload · 759K views

The Best 25 Games of the Century (So Far)
Kirk Linden · 324K views

The Real Reason Dumbledore Was WAY More Powerful Than the Others
Emily Morton · 12K views

What Is Night City's Unemployment Rate?
Any Austin · 2.3M views

I played Batman Arkham Asylum for the first time ever
Next Game Up · 1.1K views

Hogwarts & Founders: What The Movies NEVER Told You
StickmanHarry · 135K views