Ads skipped

I Respond to 49ers Fans! Kyle Shanahan Has NEVER Had a QB like Brock Purdy

18K views · Sep 26, 2026 · Sports

Up & Adams Show with Kay Adams

543K subscribers

Comments · 95

@UpAndAdamsShow · 1 day ago · pinned
Where would you rank Brock Purdy?!
@rolandvgomes5647 · 4 days ago
Purdy makes Shanahan system better
37
@derekchin6242 · 4 days ago
Top 5 QB. From Day One this guy proved he was exceptional.
52
@moeshak9944 · 4 days ago
No one has ever been this good this early
12
@Ishai1 · 4 days ago
"We need to start talking about Brock Purdy as a top 10 QB"? Kay, that's the conversation from 3-4 years ago when his numbers showed what he is and the media was struggling because it meant once again their entire pre-draft coverage was a joke. <br><br>This isn't the conversation anymore. It's where in the top 3 is he and arm strength is completely irrelevant to real QB play. The whole list of QBs who never took their team to a SuperBowl is below him too. Because QBs that can't deliver when it really counts are missing the most critical quality no matter how far they can throw a ball.
29
@TheBigBigSean · 4 days ago
David Lombardi, 49ers reporter, does analytics. The data proves that Purdy is #1 in a ton of key stats.
27
@superman6338 · 4 days ago
it should be a top 5 convo
12
@salemram15 · 4 days ago
Top 10 was a few years ago, the debate now is top 5. Get with the times!
11
@isaiahaaronnn · 4 days ago
He’s top 2 rn. It’s Josh Allen & Brock Purdy as the best right now.
18
@LorneJamesB · 4 days ago
Thank you Kay for stating the facts. Brock has outperformed every QB that has ever played under Shanahan. Regardless of the team around him.
5
@kcsne · 4 days ago
Talk to Nick..cause every Purdy's TD he calls it Kyle's  touch down
13
@PaulLeach123 · 4 days ago
You can make a great recipe but you need someone who can actually make it - and great chefs elevate the recipes (a recipe on its own is just words on a page)
9