Big Blue TRADES for J.J McCarthy BUT lose one of their stars! | Blue Rush

Comments · 24

• AL

  @alexc2680 · 1 day ago

  If it was Joe and Daboll in charge, the season would be over.  With Harbs,  we're 2-1 and 2-0 at home. There's a chance our season isn't over by Halloween and that's an improvement.  Let Harbs cook 🏈💪

  6

• SE

  @SeanCollins-y4v · 1 day ago

  Great show guys!

• AL

  @alexc2680 · 1 day ago

  Joey Porter Jr would look good in NYG Blue 💪

  2

• JW

  @jwyzdm · 1 day ago (edited)

  The story of McCarthy will mirror that of Baker Mayfield with proper coaching. And we have that proper coaching. With Dart and JJ could it be similar to when 49er's had Montana and Young. LFGG!!!

  2

• SE

  @SeanCollins-y4v · 1 day ago (edited)

  Hey Brandon. Listen to Carl Banks talk about the lack of pressure narrative on the Bleav in Giants podcast. He did acknowledge a number of times that Ward had plenty of time but that was later in the game when Wilson had more guys in coverage and the Titans were in max protection. The vast minority of times especially in the 1st half, Ward had the ball out in less than 2.5 seconds. Of course that worked out to one 1st down for the Titans. Encourage you to listen to that podcast and see what you think.

• AL

  @alandreyer2857 · 23 hours ago

  One comment made on JJ was how often does a team give up on a 1st round QB after 10 games. Ward was the 1st pick and look how bad he looks 3 games into his second season.

• MA

  @marriageoutpost · 1 day ago

  Guys, you gotta give James Winston a chance you guys are being way too panicky and JJ. McCarthy is not the answer to the second coming of dart he has improving anything yet I think that the Giants will be very unserved if they just grab JJ McCarthy and just throw him in there because he’s younger and he can run a little bit. I think James is greatly disrespected because of his personality. Yes he’s had some differences as it relates to turnovers in his career but the God has thrown for over 25,000 yards and he is accomplished some things even in the midst of having one area that he needs to severely improve and that’s just protecting the football if that wasn’t the case, James would be one of the top 20 quarterbacks in the league I’m sure you guys are in a better situation than you think

  2

• MO

  @moose14756 · 2 days ago

  I hope I’m wrong but this doesn’t make sense to me 😢

• JB

  @jbx.7995 · 1 day ago

  Harbaugh has to address his  backup Qb  situation , drafting a 1st round Q.B. in the next draft, we have a Jj and Dart can battle for the starting Q.B.  Winston is gone, and he can have his own Q.B, by the name of Arch Manning, that the best thing to do, go Giants

  2

• AD

  @adamremson6201 · 2 days ago

  Arvell Reese 3 year career??? Maybe you meant 3 game career?

  2

• PA

  @PaulNemeth-x9p · 2 days ago

  Love the JJ trade. We got him for nothing. Anyone is better than Winston.

  7

• IN

  @intrepidfool · 1 day ago (edited)

  Kevin O'Connell is a terrible QB guy and his offensive scheme is broken. What QB has had success with him besides Stafford with the Rams? Cousins had a down year and was injured. Darnold learned from Shannahan, not KOC. The scheme KOC still runs is the 2021 Rams offense designed by McVay. McVay continues to evolve, but KOC is incapable. Which is why he cannot adapt to his own personnel or to defensive adjustment. The Lions and Rams put the blueprint out on how to shut KOC down at the end of 2024 and all of the QBs, including Darnold, have been awful with KOC since then. KOC is a snake oil salesman and fraud who has gaslit the hell out of the media to scapegoat McCarthy. The failing was with KOC and McCarthy has a ton of upside. Not many 21 year old kids are equipped to deal with a sociopathic head coach. His only real emotional flaw was being too honest and earnest, expecting truth and integrity from those around him. He has been disillusioned of that naivety and will likely thrive with Harbaugh and the NY Giants. Meanwhile, Murray in his first start (as an eight year vet) was worse than any game from McCarthy last season (as a first year starter). But Murray gets a pass while McCarthy gets no grace? KOC is the problem. And when McCarthy does well with the Giants, KOC will blame Teasley for the trade, just like he blamed Kwesi, to try and save his own skin. Teflon skin and a cancer to the organization. Should have been fired with Kwesi to avoid this circus. Giants fans are in for a pleasant surprise with McCarthy, I think.