Ads skipped

My Finished Fugue Against ChatGPT Astra

184K views · Sep 11, 2026 · Education

Comments · 824

  • @MusicaUniversalis · 2 weeks ago · pinned

    Comparison starts at <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qRyaIMi7AV8&amp;t=316">5:16</a> for those who don’t want to listen to me talk.

    110

  • @alesgabriel85 · 2 weeks ago

    Astra produced the Uncanny Valley of music, it&apos;s almost there but it&apos;s like a zombie version of a real fugue

    229

  • @RyanMacMcC · 2 weeks ago

    Artistically, there is simply no comparison, but objectively the GPT6 fugue is passable as an A-deserving undergraduate music student taking a counterpoint class, and therein lies the problem...

    392

  • @giannottister · 2 weeks ago

    As Robert Schumann wrote: &apos;The most insipid head can hide behind a fugue; but a true fugue is the affair of a great master&apos;.

    72

  • @hojowarf6488 · 2 weeks ago

    You put in what the ai left out. Rhythmic interest and syncopation, deceptive cadences, satisfying and interesting cadences, stressful suspensions. As long as the machine can&apos;t feel it will never know the importance of these elements.

    370

  • @NmonicMusic · 2 weeks ago (edited)

    There&apos;s genuinely no point of comparison. <br>It feels like a quick draft you wrote while taking a dump bathroom against something you sat pondering at for 3 weeks straight, 6 hours a day. <br><br>Truly phenomenal work. <br>Might favorite part might be around <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qRyaIMi7AV8&amp;t=590">9:50</a>.

    174

  • @JvanLiempt · 2 weeks ago

    Honestly, the Fugue produced by Astra is fairly impressive in that it is not utterly disgusting hot garbage. &nbsp;Compared to a lot of musical AI stuff I have seen, it&apos;s a remarkable improvement.

    57

  • @hdb28091 · 2 weeks ago

    your fugue was heartbreaking.

    51

  • @anoNEMOs · 2 weeks ago (edited)

    I was afraid i wouldn&apos;t be able to tell the difference, since i&apos;m not that knowledgeable about fugues, but the AI one literally felt like nothing, while the human one had so much emotion

    236

  • @daveydoodle52 · 2 weeks ago

    Being aware of how quickly AI is evolving and its growing existential threat to us, I hear your beautiful fugue as an elegy to humanity.

    99

  • @DanieleMiani-bp3qn · 2 weeks ago

    obviously your fugue is a thousand times better that chatgpt&apos;s. but still, let alone the comparison with AI, your fugue is SO BEAUTIFUL😍😍😍😍 I&apos;m literally obsessed, I hope I&apos;ll get to compose as good as you one day.

    28

  • @josemiguelmaciasvocar2690 · 2 weeks ago

    <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qRyaIMi7AV8&amp;t=568">9:28</a> a bot wouldn&apos;t think of writing such a moving modulation

    17

Up next

LIVE

Mozart Humiliates Salieri, A Breakdown

Ben Laude · 553K views

LIVE

Anthropic Took On the Riemann Hypothesis. Here’s What Actually Happened

Ellie Sleightholm · 489K views

LIVE

Learn Treble Clef Notes Fast – “Name the Note” Piano Drill | Hawkspur Music Fast Practise 0022

Hawkspur Music · 48 views

LIVE

Notation Must Die: The Battle For How We Read Music

Tantacrul · 1.7M views

LIVE

"Fur Elise isn't supposed to sound like this!" Concert Pianist Reviews Rousseau

Peterson Piano Academy · 199K views

LIVE

The Best Chord Ever Created

Pedro Erdei-Gonzaga · 13K views

LIVE

Nigel's Most Mysterious Move Isn't Even A Word

Will Anderson · 1.1M views

LIVE

polymicrotonality goes kinda hard ngl

Levi McClain · 110K views

LIVE

Fugue: AI vs. Human

Musica Universalis · 190K views

LIVE

The Dumbest Human Moments On The Internet

Daily Dose Of Internet · 10M views

LIVE

The Impossible Challenge of Playing Adolf Hitler | Acting Breakdown

The Back Focus · 1.4M views

LIVE

Why the "Moonlight" Sonata was REVOLUTIONARY

Peterson Piano Academy · 87K views

LIVE

The Cult of Jacob Collier

Sor Hands · 211K views

LIVE

The last IMO problem AI could not solve

3Blue1Brown and PolyaMath · 2.6M views

LIVE

The Infinite Wisdom Of JS Bach

The Music Professor · 54K views

LIVE

The Best Scrabble Player is GENUINELY insane

s0ngbird · 12M views

LIVE

Ex-Anthropic insider tells CNN how AI could kill all humans by 2030

CNN · 9.7M views

LIVE

Dumb AI Security Flaw Ruins Scam Call Center

Kitboga · 812K views

LIVE

What Rick Beato Gets Wrong About Bach

The Music Professor · 126K views

LIVE

James May tests weird TV gadgets

James May’s Planet Gin · 273K views

YouTube, with the door locked.

Aegis plays a clean stream instead of YouTube's player, so pre-roll ads, trackers, and fingerprinting never ride along. Drop Shields any time if you want the official player back.