Nostalgia Critic is WRONG About Pirates of the Caribbean - Part 1 - A Rage-Filled Response

Comments · 419

• TH

  @TheSEAempire · 3 years ago · pinned

  Thanks for watching! Here are all my links: <br> <br>Patreon: <a href="https://www.patreon.com/the_s_e_a/membership">https://www.patreon.com/the_s_e_a/membership </a><br> <br>Merch: <a href="https://www.theseasemporium.com/">https://www.theseasemporium.com/ </a><br> <br>Discord: <a href="https://discord.gg/D7bjFJ58az">https://discord.gg/D7bjFJ58az</a>

  13

• MO

  @MoonwatcherTheNightWing-WoF · 1 year ago

  The use of the &apos;Not Funny, Didn&apos;t Laugh&apos; is funnier than Nostalgia Critic&apos;s attempts at a joke.

  31

• SH

  @ShyThalia · 2 years ago

  I thought it was obvious that Jack saying &quot;It would never have worked between us, darling&quot; to Elizabeth was a joke that stemmed from him having a &quot;crush&quot; on her because she&apos;s a pretty girl. He never seemed like someone who was ever interested in any actual romantic relationship, not even with her. So, it&apos;s weird for NC to count that as a &quot;tease&quot; when it doesn&apos;t seem like one.

  16

• EL

  @elruffian163 · 3 years ago

  I never watched any of the movies until this year .for me they not perfect but a lot of fun and enjoy binge watching all of them. Barbosa has to be my favorite character hands down.

  72

• EL

  @ElvenRaptor · 2 years ago

  The way Doug Walker reviews films, he even rips apart films he likes (or claims to like), like his review of the original &quot;Jurassic Park&quot;, which he savages like no tomorrow despite claiming to be a fan. And insulted Jeff Goldblum multiple times.

  85

• AN

  @anonymousanonymous6796 · 1 year ago

  I remember his review of POTC 2 &amp; 3 being simply = its too complicated.

  12

• GR

  @Grey8270 · 2 years ago

  The worst part of Doug’s review besides the long cringy skits is how he actively removes context from scenes to tear down films like cinema sins

  157

• AM

  @amberbradshaw1461 · 2 years ago

  &quot;There might be some strong language used in this video.... <br><br>Me: I AM SO IN!

  7

• AR

  @ARCtheCartoonMaster · 3 years ago

  <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=naHTZ7wFnkY&amp;t=854">14:14</a> I&apos;m... pretty sure his point is that the character is written well enough that the audience cares about her.

  30

• TH

  @TheCow-j1l · 2 years ago

  this feels like a nostalgia critic review of a nostalgia critic video lol, nostalgia critic-ception

  16

• DM

  @dminorpictures5403 · 2 years ago

  While I think Barbossa&apos;s line &quot;I feel cold&quot; is fantastic and incredibly poignant (BTW great job explaining why the line works so well!), I can understand what Doug means by thinking the dialogue he thought he heard was better than what was actually said.<br><br>When I was a child watching At World&apos;s End, when Will stabs Davy Jones in the chest, I thought Jones said &quot;Missed&quot; as in Will missed the mark of killing Jones so incredibly hard he wasn&apos;t even close. But I only found out a couple years ago that what Jones actually said was &nbsp;&quot;Mister...&quot; and then he proceeds to ask if Will forgot he was heartless. It kind of upsets me a little bit because as a kid, I thought the idea of Jones getting stabbed in the chest and then cheekily saying &quot;Missed&quot; just gave him another level of sass and felt very in-character for Jones. <br><br>So I can understand where Doug is coming from in this situation, but I think the actual line Barbossa says before he dies works way better.

  16

• AR

  @ARCtheCartoonMaster · 3 years ago

  <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=naHTZ7wFnkY&amp;t=677">11:17</a> I think he does the blackouts so YouTube will trigger an ad.

  15