Lindsay Clancy: Cold-Blooded Murder or Postpartum Psychosis?

On a January night in 2023, Patrick Clancy left his house in Duxbury, Massachusetts to pick up takeout and a medication. What he came home to would put his wife at the center of the most watched trial this summer. Because Lindsay Clancy was a labor and delivery nurse who'd spent years guiding other mothers through the hardest hours of their lives, and who knew the warning signs better than almost anyone. In this episode, Sabrina and Kaelyn follow the clues: a psychiatric record of escalating prescriptions and a patient who kept asking for changes. A husband who testified for the prosecution and asked for mercy anyway. And a jury sent out to choose between murder and manslaughter. By the end, the jury still couldn't agree on any of it. Chapters: 0:00 Introduction 4:33 January 24th, 2023 8:56 Who Are The Clancy’s? 18:26 The Investigation Begins 21:29 The Trial Begins 36:14 Evidence #1: Mental Health History 53:32 Evidence #2: Lindsay's Suicide Attempt 1:00:40 Evidence #3: Lindsay's Story (Secondhand) 1:07:23 Evidence #4: The Exercise Bands 1:09:42 Evidence #5: The Premeditated Errand Debate 1:12:08 Evidence #6: The Timeline and The Upstairs Phone 1:18:05 Evidence #7: The 911 Tape 1:21:11 What Actually Matters 1:24:06 Resolution 1:29:57 Activism 1:32:45 Missing Person of the Week: Andrew Amato 1:33:47 Outro Episode Sponsors: Save up to 61% off with free gifts with code CLUES at https://www.gruns.co Get started now at ⁠⁠https://www.HelloAlma.com/CLUES Some crimes are solved by a single clue — one overlooked fingerprint, a missing puzzle piece, or a detail hiding in plain sight. Clues, a Crime House Original from PAVE Studios, takes you deep into the world of notorious crimes and forensic breakthroughs. If you're obsessed with forensic twists, cold cases, and the relentless pursuit of justice— hit subscribe and uncover your next true crime obsession. New video episodes drop every Wednesday! #Clues #CluesPodcast #KaelynMoore #Crime #CrimePodcast #PAVEStudios Subscribe to never miss a moment!: @cluespod ABOUT CLUES: Hosted by Kaelyn Moore, Clues unpacks the cases that gripped the world—from chilling murders to serial killers. Each episode dissects the evidence, retraces investigative breakthroughs, and follows the trail of clues that cracked the case—or left it hauntingly unsolved. Clues is a Crime House original, powered by PAVE Studios. WHERE TO LISTEN: Spotify – https://open.spotify.com/show/0EdKvs7... Apple – https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast... STAY CONNECTED WITH CLUES: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/cluespodcas... Follow Kaelyn: https://www.instagram.com/itskaelynmo... ============================= Copyright Notice: This video and my YouTube channel contain dialog, music, and images that are property of Clues Podcast. You are authorized to share the video link and channel, and embed this video in your website or others as long as a link back to my YouTube Channel is provided. © 2025 Clues Podcast