Prosecuting Attorney Paul Watkins gives rebuttal closing argument in the Caleb Flynn murder case
63K views · Sep 29, 2026 · News & Politics
Comments · 235
@amandalwayman4046 · 1 day ago
Watkins did an excellent job. Perfect mix of laying out evidence and injecting just the right amount of emotion. I’m so glad Ashley got a voice in this prosecution team.
99
@zenosperformance1125 · 1 day ago
Kudos to Mr Watkins closing. Well done sir.
126
@MidwestMama17 · 1 day ago
This was easily one of the top 5 rebuttal closings I have ever seen. Paul Watkins is SO good at what he does! Well done! 👏🏻👏🏻
109
@elizahJ · 1 day ago
This rebuttal was a masterpiece
133
@bjlass3470 · 1 day ago
I pray they now go after the douche mistress. She pushed and pushed for him to get rid of Ashley and …she didn’t care how.
81
@sharonmikalauski6503 · 1 day ago
One of the absolute BEST rebuttals to date. The States attorney did an amazing job 👏💣. Applause, applause!!
42
@hedykarim3614 · 1 day ago
Ashleigh’s poor family and loved ones , I can imagine their pain and heartbreak. God put your arms around this family .
58
@fembot521 · 1 day ago (edited)
I cannot wait for Caleb to be sentenced to life in prison and Aleighas life ruined. This is a stellar prosecution team. RIP Ashley ❤
53
@Marie623nyc · 1 day ago
Great close rebuttal— he covered every angle and wrapped it all up clean and tight for the jury.
30
@senzekilebuthelezi8391 · 1 day ago (edited)
Thanks to the prosecutor attorney Paul, i am praying and hoping that justice will be served for Ashley. <br><br>She was nothing but a loving mother, a wife who wanted to make her marriage work. <br><br>Caleb and his mistress dehumanized her so much that executing her seemed like nothing. Rest in peace Ashley
39
@Violet12224 · 23 hours ago
Mr. Watkins is a very impressive lawyer. He really brought it together, and his speech is so clear (not an "um, ah" in sight) that listening to him is a delight. His opening and rebuttal was just outstanding.
22
@tonyknight2119 · 23 hours ago
It shocks me that he actually pled not guilty and took this to trial. I don't think I seen any more clear-cut case of somebody guilty of murder in my life
26
Up next

Caleb Flynn's Defense Attorney Patrick Mulligan gives closing argument in murder trial
East Idaho News · 26K views

WATCH: Caleb Flynn sobs as judge reads verdict in murder case
East Idaho News · 473K views

PART ONE | Caleb Flynn's mistress Alleigha Botner testifies in his murder trial
East Idaho News · 379K views

Caleb Flynn Trial: VERDICT
Lawyer You Know · 235K views

23 Disturbing Details Dropped in Crying Pastor’s Murder Trial
Law&Crime Network · 437K views

'Crybaby' Pastor LOSES IT in Court as Jury Slaps Him with Verdict
Law&Crime Network · 339K views

FULL TESTIMONY | Caleb Flynn's Sister-In-Law Kayla Keyt testifies in his murder trial
East Idaho News · 281K views

Mistress Testifies Day 1 — OH v. Caleb Flynn — Pastor’s Deadly Sin Trial
Law&Crime Trials · 39K views

The Psychology of Staging: Caleb Flynn’s First Account | Profiling Evil
Profiling Evil · 62K views

‘Crybaby’ Caleb Flynn Tears Up During Closing Arguments
COURT TV · 114K views

Ohio Jury Convicts Caleb Flynn Of All Counts For Murdering Wife
Meghann Cuniff · 39K views

Ashley Flynn's Father Tells the Staged Scene Jury the Intruder Story Made No Sense to Him | Pt 10
Justice Is A Process!!!! · 21K views

Lindsay Clancy Appears In Court For 1st Time Since Mistrial — Entire Hearing
Meghann Cuniff · 15K views

Pastor’s Mistress — Full Direct Testimony — OH v. Caleb Flynn
Law&Crime Trials · 112K views

FULL TESTIMONY | Caleb Flynn's Mother-In-Law Jill Smith testifies in his murder trial
East Idaho News · 342K views

CALEB FLYNN GUILTY ON ALL COUNTS | Watch the Verdict & Billy Bush’s Live Reaction
Hot Mics with Billy Bush · 134K views

Caleb Flynn GUILTY on All 9 Counts — His Reaction & What Happens Next (Trial Day 8)
Lawyer Lee · 161K views

Lindsay Clancy’s Lawyer STUNS Court With Legal Maneuver
COURT TV · 202K views

The “American Idol Murder” Trial: The FULL Backstory & Bombshell First Week | Caleb Flynn
Hidden True Crime · 181K views

Ashley Flynn’s Mother Takes The Stand — Full Testimony
Law&Crime Trials · 205K views