Where did People of India and Other Parts of South, Central Asia Come From?

Comments · 1.4K

• NI

  @niranjanaich6325 · 7 years ago

  Why so much hatred in the comment section?  We are all pure indians. No matter how we look. Migration happened in every country so in India and other South Asian countries. In the video they are just talk how migration happened and from which parts of the world. They are not trying to divide us.

  268

• DI

  @dionisiodussart5629 · 2 years ago

  The IE migration map shown, starting at <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_BCXAUEBgO4&amp;t=120">2:00</a>, is outrageously simplified.<br>1) Sintashta Culture (South Oural), that gave the Andronovo Culture (Central Asia) didn&apos;t descend directly from Yamnaya Culture (the initial one, in Southern Russia) but from a 75% Yamnaya people : Balto-Slavic Europeans belonging (like many other Europeans at that time) to the Corded Ware Culture, that they exported till Central Asia.<br>2) Some Yamnaya people had, far before that European movement to the East, had gone extremely far to the East, reaching Altaï Mountains where they created the Afanassievo Culture... NOT to confuse with Andronovo Culture from where stemmed the Indo-Aryans after their brutal, necessary brutal and murderous (no politically correct BS was present at that time) collision with the Oxus Civilization.

  5

• CH

  @chhandasarkar6094 · 8 years ago

  A great attempt to explain how civilisations developed in Eurasia based on a very work. This is may be the very first of it&apos;s kind in Indian web channels. As a viewer want more of such programs. Like to suggest that whole program perhaps much easier to understand if divided into 4/5 parts, using along side &nbsp;the time bar, topography, land elevation and &nbsp; <br>flow of various ethnic gruops and their provable mixing. Plus separate episode for major language gruops and ethnic groups. Thank you newsclick.

  52

• DI

  @DineshKumar-in6oi · 3 years ago

  More than Excellent speech and description!

  2

• DA

  @DavidSaintloth · 8 years ago

  Excellent technical discussion on the latest work in this area...would love to see more. We Scientist need to stop dumbing down our work when relaying it to laymen....it&apos;s time to bootstrap the human family....in this critical time such clear thinking and respect for rigor is super important for us to find the solutions that will allow us to minimize the discord on the way from our many mistakes in steward of this one planet that we all share, that can harbor our life.

  25

• RO

  @rockstar14721 · 6 years ago

  Yes the people from Eurasia migrated long time back to India but not all of us are very mixed and Indian irrespective of our genetic ancestry .

  2

• SO

  @solprab · 6 years ago (edited)

  Very informative video and so much of information is covered. Every time I listen to it I understand something more which I missed the previous time.<br>And for the people fighting in the comment section about Aryan/Dravidian, North vs South controversies, the genetic difference between all of us Indians and even south Asians as a whole doesn&apos;t have any clean divide of 2 groups. All of us are admixture of Ancestral North Indian and Ancestral South Indian population groups. Of course there is a gradient of high to low proportion of ANI when you go further south into India from the North. <br>Not even everyone speaking the same language and identifying as same cast today is going to have similar admixture of ANI and ASI. To put it in simple terms if you test the DNA of everyone in a caste group within a single state in India you will find a varying admixture of ANI and ASI.<br>So moral of the story: All of these studies and findings should excite us Indians that we are all a mixed group and very closely related to each other genetically no matter what language we speak and where we live in India now.

  43

• MR

  @mrkunalgoswami2010 · 8 years ago

  wow || someone is trying for basics of our history. ................. Great ........

  7

• SH

  @shahminhajuddin · 7 years ago

  Very interesting though complex to comprehend fully !<br>Probably should have had focused more on my geography classes 😆

  13

• BL

  @bluepebbles7885 · 6 years ago

  Thirty years ago i remember one man who found the relationship between sumerian elamites and dravidian language! Now he is correct.

  49

• MI

  @mikeanglada742 · 5 years ago

  Luv Ya India, from the USA! &lt;3

  86

• RO

  @roncherian5598 · 7 years ago

  Sir... appreciated your efforts...but pls make it little more simple way ... quite complicated for common man...sorry sir

  9