What Makes A Horror Game “Gripping”? Amnesia The Bunker Vs. Alien Isolation
16K views · 12 Apr 2025
Comments · 122
@guy_mcdude · 1 year ago
Blows me away that this video only has less than 200 views. Insane
49
@jonathanshepherd-z7b · 1 day ago
I used the ammo to summon the Alien on a few occasions when there were groups of Scavengers that I needed to get past. <br><br>I'd hide until all the scavengers were around, pop one of them in the leg or shoulder before getting back in my hiding spot and then let the Alien turn them into Ramen. <br><br>So much fun.
1
@scottedwards8220 · 1 month ago
Fantastic video. I disagree slightly on a few things. I think personal tolerance is a maaaaaajor factor. You started to slip at the halfway point. I slipped at the end, slightly. <br><br>I did a recent second playthrough and got the platinum trophy. I made it to about the same point before I started to slip.<br><br>I felt the 3 hour gap without the alien was a decent breather. Taking the weapons for 1 mission didn't affect me at all. <br><br>The ring around the Rosie comment is spot on. <br><br>They developed a fantastic game and I hope they can tighten it up a bit more in regard to the Alien vision etc. <br><br>To sum up, I think your review is perfectly valid. You took your time, and you have a different tolerance for certain elements versus me. <br><br>To sum up the IGN review, he stumbled onto some valid points, but his problems all stem more from trying to rush something that was designed with game review deadlines in mind. The two similar points come from a one neutral and one biased point of view to get to similar conclusions, but a vastly different evaluation of the total package. <br><br>Back to the ring around the Rosie element , and this isn't giving credit to AI, but there is a mod that makes that impossible and it's a load of fun.
4
@Los_Freddos · 1 year ago
How come I haven't seen this until now! 😮 Thoroughly enjoyed this! Great vid and a big thank you from us!<br>/Fredrik from Frictional
44
@TruMediaMix · 2 months ago
As someone who's played both of these games, I can safely say that the only real reason you're using items to throw 'em away and make room for your inventory is - at best - a skill issue.<br><br>The xenomorph punishes you for predictable problem solving patterns and for not fully paying attention to your surroundings. Yes, your revolver will attract a xenomorph's attention, but the same logic applies to Amnesia: The Bunker. Both games also give you a shotgun that WILL momentarily shoo off their respective monsters in the same way molotov cocktails do.<br><br>You can also use your aformentioned guns to shoot barrels and various other hazards.
9
@raiden4886 · 1 year ago
no fucking WAY, The Thing is my top horror film and Alien is my 2nd. Good taste man
14
@gregor_samsa_real · 3 months ago
I love how in the bunker, you aren't the only one that can (or will) make mistakes. On my first run I was in the Arsenal, and the Beast came out for me, and in its haste it tripped a grenade trap and ran off. As it ran off, it tripped 3 other traps and carved out an easy exit path for me. I love how unscripted the beast is at all times.
2
@andrewlorentzen8236 · 1 year ago
A 20 sub channel putting more effort into multi million channel. Please keep up the amazing work I really wish to see more of your videos
21
@aceyspud551 · 1 year ago
The only thing more dangerous than the Xenomorph is criticising Alien Isolation, but it definitely lasted too long and once the novelty of the difficulty and its random elements wore off, it would get frustrating. The short length of the Bunker helped it stay scary, and even if you DO figure the Beast out and conquer your fear, you still have a more fun game than Isolation because instead of frequently fucking you over and wasting your time, you usually only die if you screw up.
17
@BooyahgButcher · 12 days ago
Obviously Agrippa makes Amnesia gripping, but he can't grip after you cut his head off so it stops being Agripping.
1
@dragonmaster3030 · 6 months ago
One of the things I love about the bunker is it's self made loop of tension. You have four main things going against you that being time, sound, the beast, and yourself. You determine how much sound you make which can increase or decrease time spent accordingly, the beast runs on its own schedule as well as outside influence that if which being yourself. Time determines everything, where you go, how the beast acts and the level of sound. If your running out of time you may make more noise to speed up wether it be running or grenade, even if you have time you still have to pick and choose when to be fast and when to slow down within your limit. Being in one place too long also attracts the beast so you can't just hole up somewhere. There's also a level of unpredictablity with the beast, he can lay traps from holes and may cause increase use of time depending on his actions, something you can't exactly account for yet have to navigate swiftly and tactfully. Resource usage can be added onto these 4 core problems presented to you if your on shell shocked. <br><br>In short you tend to create your own limits and problems and resources can help alleviate or even produce the situations itself. The beast is your main enemy but it's influenced by everything you do. Sound and time are the biggest things you have to work around and utilize effectively with or without the help of tools. It becomes a self feedback loop of challenges you have to overcome in some crafty way to progress or on higher difficulties just to survive.<br><br>(Also don't play shell shocked on a first playthrough, I did and damn it became near impossible)
7
@MoreLikeDanny · 7 months ago
I remember reading something about the lower areas of the ship having bars, wires, pipes and tubes that are supposed to trick the viewers into being paranoid that they keep seeing the alien, I think the alien is even in a couple of these shots but you'd have to know where on the screen to look or you'd miss it every time. <br><br>I tried to look for both of these things the last time I watched the film, I definitely see the pipes, wires and hoses but I couldn't find the alien hiding in any shots
4
Up next

Alien: Isolation - A Comprehensive Analysis
muh bruh · 164K views

Amnesia The Bunker Learns From Your Mistakes
Mikey Lee · 355K views

Why IGN’s Alien Isolation Review is an Insult to Journalism
Rayl Deal Games · 572K views

"Difficulty" Isn't the Point of Dark Souls | 4Score Game Reviews
4Score Game Reviews · 14K views

Does Alien: Isolation Have THE SAUCE?
Big Britches · 1.6K views

Pursuers: The Design Behind Gaming's Scariest Monsters
Raccoon Thumbs · 128K views

The Alien Vs Predator Movies are Really Stupid
Jay Cote · 616K views

Dead Space Remake Review: Survival Horror Tension Perfected | 4Score Game Reviews
4Score Game Reviews · 419 views

The Most Horrifying Post-Apocalypse
Muldered · 1.1M views

Amnesia: The Bunker is a Masterclass in Horror Game Design
Purposeless Rabbitholes · 1M views

What is Leviathan in Hellraiser?
Volrusk · 1.3M views

Alien: Isolation Is the Best Game I Never Want to Play Again
MISSINGMO. · 54K views

Why Scorn is the Most Disturbing Game Ever Made
Fuzduf · 1.7M views

Bioshock: The Masterpiece That Streamlined Too Much | 4Score Game Reviews
4Score Game Reviews · 277 views

The Desperation of Amnesia: The Bunker
Connor McGrath · 45K views

The Horrors of Alien Isolation
CritSh0tZ · 262K views

Why Are War Games Not Horror Games?
Pim's Crypt · 37K views

How speedrunners beat Alien: Isolation in 22 minutes (SPEEDRUN EXPLAINED - Any%)
tomatoanus · 1.7M views

The Accidental HORROR Behind Subnautica
MickyboyGames · 338K views

Chaos Theory 20 Years Later: When the Splinter Cell Series Peaked - 4Score Game Reviews
4Score Game Reviews · 371 views