Ликвидация ФСБ, как быть с доносчиками и ошибки 90-х. Альбац, Гуриев, Павлов, Солдатов, Бороган

The "What Is to Be Done?" Project. Read more about reforms in post-Putin Russia — https://www.reforms.io/ The role of the secret services in Russia: how we allowed this to happen, and how to reform them when the opportunity for reform opens. Evgenia Albats, Ivan Pavlov, Irina Borogan, and Andrei Soldatov — in the new season of Sergei Guriev and TV Rain's joint project — the talk show "What Is to Be Done?" 00:00 Start 00:40 The role of the secret services and how to reform them 01:26 Albats: There are no secret services in Russia 03:32 Soldatov: The FSB was given power 05:10: Pavlov: The FSB protects itself 06:10 Borogan: Why do we call the secret services "special"? 08:21 Albats: How all power ended up in the hands of the KGB 10:08 Guriev: Why does Putin think the system is effective? 11:10 Pavlov: Why the chance was missed. Why there was no reform of the intelligence services. 12:20 "The entire country is in the FSB's thrall." 12:43 Borogan: How Putin controls information, how it is supplied to him. 14:50 Albats: The power of the purse outside the military structure. 17:50 Shut down the FSB completely? 18:40 Pavlov: Destroy it to the ground. 19:32 The powers of the FSB. 24:01 Will an FSB officer be able to transfer to a new intelligence service? 25:05 Borogan: The powers of the intelligence services will be narrowed. 26:23 "They are not fools and will take revenge." 27:31 How to conduct lustration. 29:18 "The situation is monstrous." Why is it so much worse now than in 1991. 31:25 Albats. People had a vested interest in keeping the archives from being opened. 35:11 Albats: The first task is to open the archives immediately. 35:45 Rebuilding the service. The experience of other countries. 38:15 Albats and Pavlova debate. 39:53 Soldatov. "The FSB isn't the only one involved in repression." 41:16 An example of judicial reform. Where will judges come from? 42:00 Where will the security forces go? 44:06 Borogan. Crime must be punished. 46:00 FSB chat. How to bring criminals to justice. 48:46 How to prevent them from returning. 49:04 Should Lubyanka be demolished? A dispute between participants. 51:04 What to do with FSB informants and informants? 57:06 Secret agents are the beneficiaries of the policy of repression 58:32 "We cannot leave these people with the ability to blackmail" 1:02:24 Question: What to do with nuclear weapons security and other intelligence agencies 1:06:16 Question: How to control what is beyond the control of society 1:06:47 Borogan: A very small intelligence agency will be needed 1:08:42 Pavlov. Who will represent the new regime? 1:09:36 Question: What relevant experience is needed to build new intelligence agencies 1:13:21 Albats. We don't need a repressive agency to be effective 1:14:26 Civilian structures for oversight of intelligence agencies 1:16:32 Let's summarize. 1:18:17 Sodatov. Intelligence agencies are part of imperial ideology 1:19:55 Albats. It's not a question of personalities. The KGB's only dissident ___________________________ 🩷 SUPPORT US WITH A DONATION IF YOU'RE NOT IN RUSSIA: https://e.tvrain.tv/donate_talk-show Watch the video version of Sonya Shats's podcast in the Dozhd app: https://tvr.ink/Scuj Closed community "Psychology on Dozhd": streams, Q&A, and exclusive content with Svetlana Komissaruk and Eduard Burmistrov — join for a subscription starting at 20 euros: Patreon: PsychologyTVRain ___________________________ 👉 New "Psychology": betrayal and trust: ИЗМЕНЫ. Стоит ли рассказывать? Кто чаще из... 👉 New episode of Nadezhda Metalnikova's program: Главный рычаг Путина: выдержит ли Армения ... 👉 New "Mishanina." Hits of 2012: «Сочиняй мечты», «Небо поможет нам», «Кофе... ___________________________ Our social media: • Telegram: https://t.me/tvrain • Instagram: Instagram: tvrain • Twitter (X): Twitter: tvrain ___________________________ ❗️Download the new Dozhd app for Smart TV: https://www.hopp.bio/tvrain 🙏 Buy on Temu, iHerb, Skyscanner, and from our other partners - this way you will support Dozhd: https://tvr.ink/shop 📺Subscribe to the new YouTube channel "Dozhd Library": @tvrainlibrary 👑 Subscribe to the Drama Queens channel: @dramaqueens_tvrain 🙌 Subscribe to Telegram Channel 43 — news for those who want a break from the news! https://t.me/sorok_tri ___________________________ Send us news, donate, or buy advertising on Dozhd using our Telegram bot: https://t.me/raintvbot You can also contact us securely by email at [email protected] Tell us what's happening in your region so we can cover it on air. ___________________________ #news #russia Program: Talk show Type: video Host: Dzyadko Subtype: full episode