Anthony Gramuglia is Lying to You | A Critical Response

Comments · 1.7K

• WE

  @WesleyanWannabe · 11 months ago · pinned

  Buzzwords? Your the most plain speaking and clear spoken critic on all of Youtube, with every word delivered with assertive dispassionate logical factualness. We're not swept up in your videos by buzzwords we don't understand but are impressed by, we watch and appreciate your videos because they respect our intelligence by engaging with us down a logical journey through arguments and examples, and because your not just critiquing things to tear them down, your teaching us fundamental writing principles that could be useful with a interesting application. Meanwhile what does this guy do that's productive for us? Tell us to consider how movies make us feel first? Well let me tell you The Farce Awakens doesn't fare any better on the feelings front either, but now im being accused a sexist if I try asking why it feels disappointing to watch.

  328

• BF

  @bfranciscop · 11 months ago

  &quot;How the movie makes you feel is more important than the plot&quot;<br>And what, pray tell, if the movie makes me feel cringe and disgust, <i>because the plot is badly written?</i>

  891

• RO

  @robinthrush9672 · 11 months ago

  I believe the plot hole in Emperor&apos;s New Groove doesn&apos;t matter because it&apos;s a comedy and that specific plot hole is pointed out as, &quot;You got me; by all accounts it doesn&apos;t make sense,&quot; to make a joke.

  551

• KA

  @kaldheimknight · 11 months ago

  To me Ant will always be the guy who tried to use Blade Runner as an example of why plot holes &quot;don&apos;t matter&quot; then never provided a plot hole.

  91

• DE

  @Deathclaw-lh5tl · 6 months ago

  &quot;and probably cry that it took me about ten minutes to get here.&quot;<br><br>Ask and ye shall receive:<br>&quot;I don&apos;t care what you have to say because you took too long to say it.&quot; - Anthony Gramuglia&apos;s response video.

  75

• TM

  @TM_AZ · 11 months ago (edited)

  Anthony:<br>&gt;Accuses others of bad faith criticism<br>&gt;applies bad faith criticism<br><br>&gt;Accuses LD of not being fair to Rey<br>&gt;is utterly unfair to Luke while giving Rey the benefit of the doubt constantly<br><br>&gt;accuses LD of using buzzwords<br>&gt;grifter grifter grifter grifter grifter grifter <br><br>No wonder EFAP went after that vid.

  718

• RE

  @Reddotzebra · 9 months ago

  Nature Girl started her crusade &quot;for nature&quot; by coming across a dying sea turtle, one that had mistaken a plastic bag for a jellyfish, their preferred prey, and choked to death on it. She retaliates to this by finding out which chain of stores the plastic bag came from (possibly even the one specific store, I don&apos;t remember) and then killing a member of staff in cold blood. She didn&apos;t go after the people who made the bag in the first place, or the one that threw it away, she just wandered into the store the logo on the bag belonged to and stabbed a staff member in the neck with a pair of scissors. And this is the person we&apos;re supposed to cheer for? She&apos;s not a hero and she&apos;s not even a good villain, because her motivation is trash. It&apos;s literally just &quot;this is bad and it makes me angry, so I&apos;m going to take it out on the easiest target I can find and then learn nothing from the experience.&quot;

  233

• JO

  @jovenc4508 · 11 months ago

  A scavenger wouldn&apos;t always know how the parts they pull work or what they do. If Rey was raised solely as a scavenger just to pull parts then she wouldn&apos;t know anything about a functioning system, only what parts are important and valuable. If they had shown her swiping parts every so often and building a ship in secret then maybe you could make an argument.

  344

• NE

  @NerdAthleticz · 11 months ago

  Let me help everyone out, Anthony&apos;s takes are very easy to predict. If it advances leftism, it&apos;s good, if it does not advance leftism it is bad. This dude has been caught in so many lies about all forms of media (my experiences with him involve anime/manga translations). 99% of what he says can just be disregarded.

  740

• DE

  @DEUS_VULT_INFIDEL · 11 months ago

  &quot;A lesson in dragon-riding. The wholesome kind.&quot;<br>Ayo.

  305

• AP

  @ApophisTw0Thousand6309 · 11 months ago

  Isn’t Anthony Gramuglia the guy whose “deep” analysis of the Tears in the Rain speech was just slightly rephrasing what Roy Batty said? Ol’ Tony here ain’t no brainchild.

  496

• RO

  @Rolf97 · 11 months ago

  I love it when people try to use Kylo&apos;s wound to justify him losing to Mah-Rey Sue. Dark side users draw power from powerful emotions and pain, as if him BEATING HIS OPEN WOUND wasn&apos;t evidence enough!

  45