Why Have We NEVER Spoken In Poppy Playtime?

Comments · 1K

• GI

  @Gimmickvr · 6 months ago (edited)

  I think we are canonically talking, but they’re not using any voice actors to avoid revealing our identity<br><br>Did you kill her?🧸<br><br>….<br><br>Good🧸

  142

• AN

  @andpeg · 6 months ago

  We’re too locked in to talk😂

  462

• PL

  @PlayHouseCritters · 6 months ago

  Suprised the player has just not duct taped poppys mouth at this point

  642

• ST

  @strangecolouredbird · 6 months ago

  My personal theory is that the <i>player&apos;s</i> speech is supposed to be the player <i>character&apos;s</i> speech. Unlike in Banban, we&apos;ve never been called &quot;the quiet type&quot; or something like that- and Poppy actively asks us &quot;Did you kill her?&quot;, in Chapter 2. Silence. &quot;Good.&quot;<br>I think our speech, whatever we, the players controlling the character, say, is supposed to be what the player character is saying.

  41

• NO

  @Nodythe1 · 6 months ago

  Bro&apos;s the Quiet Kid 💀

  53

• AR

  @arzuna.mp4 · 4 months ago

  <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FsAXT2SzSO0&amp;t=459">7:39</a> The idea of a &apos;forced witnessing&apos; as a form of torture is so dark but fits perfectly. Our silence isnt just a game mechanic; it&apos;s the physical weight of our survivor&apos;s guilt. We didn&apos;t speak up back then to stop Playtime Co. so now we literally cannot speak. Btw brilliant video !! 😊❤

  35

• _Y

  @_YellowPlayz_ · 6 months ago

  The boring answer is mob doesn&apos;t wanna get a VA and wants us to feel like the player.<br><br>the interesting one is Either the Player is MUTE and their using sign langue half the time or they doesn&apos;t feel like talking to the toys or smth-

  558

• HA

  @Harrison_Rutherford · 6 months ago

  To be fair, if they were capable of speaking, by chapter 3 their lungs would be severely damaged from the red smoke

  367

• SU

  @SunKissed_Typa-Girl · 6 months ago

  Maybe the player was asking too many questions when they worked at Playtime Co and had to be shut up or smth.

  22

• MA

  @madisonsosa21 · 6 months ago

  I mean, I probably wouldn&apos;t say a word either.

  302

• 2S

  @2static4you · 6 months ago

  My theory is because he has extreme guilt from not going to his work when it was the hour of joy, extreme guilt can lead to mutism under a lot of circumstances.

  127

• AN

  @antoinettebruce6384 · 6 months ago (edited)

  I think mob wants the player to stay silent so they can keep bros identity a secret until the big reveal, this kinda hints that we have heard ourselves on a vhs tape, so if the bro speaks and we have heard ourselves on a tape that would reveal the player easily.

  163