Resurrection Scholar DOESN'T LIKE my Fact-Checking! (Gary Habermas response)

Comments · 1.7K

• JA

  @JamesFodor · 1 year ago (edited) · pinned

  Thanks for the shoutout! We skeptics need to work together to combat the resurrection nonsense from apologists.

  379

• IL

  @ilmt · 1 year ago

  While the books weigh over 13 pounds, they carry no weight inside....

  182

• TH

  @TheRabydAtheist · 1 year ago (edited)

  Wow, thanks for the shout out and using me in your video. I don't know how he denies that he lied. He did not say "Evengelicals" vs. other Christians. He said 'non-beleivers'. If he had done this right out the gate I would be less critical, but he made the impression that there were more non-Christians, than Christians.  Truly disappointing and quite frankly he is gaslighting the rest of us.

  271

• AV

  @avi8r66 · 1 year ago

  Gary's upset because the majority of this 'evidence' was debunked before he published.

  734

• RE

  @realLsf · 1 year ago

  It’s got to be embarrassing for Gary that a “YouTube skeptic” has totally undermined his magnum opus work on the resurrection. Not only has he been debunked but he’s also been shown to be dishonest; shameful. Keep up the good work, Paul. Can’t wait for your book to come out

  283

• SA

  @SapientCephalopod · 1 year ago

  Real scholars don't sign "statements of faith". If you sign one, you have zero credibility.

  258

• LO

  @lordsrednuas · 1 year ago

  Nothing makes the resurrection seem less likely than listening to Gary defend it.

  330

• SA

  @Sapphire_GaySapiens_Light · 1 year ago

  Habermas framing this as a Left vs Right issue feels really gross.

  382

• GR

  @Gritmonger · 1 year ago

  Not just living rent free in his head. Moved in, redid the walls, maybe changed out the furniture, set up a long-term lease, considered then rejected a new coffee table...

  164

• KE

  @Kevin-Dietz · 1 year ago

  After that, he was seen by over 500 scholars at the same time, some of whom are still alive.

  755

• RO

  @Rotaretilbo · 1 year ago

  <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BiHBnXc0V2E&amp;t=1149">19:09</a> I love how Gary is like &quot;Oh, I couldn&apos;t <i>possibly</i> say, I cannot say what&apos;s in someone&apos;s heart and would not want to make any judgments,&quot; and Mike is like &quot;Okay, but like Bart Ehrman self-identifies as a non-believer,&quot; and Gary&apos;s immediately like &quot;Sure, let me start listing people I personally consider non-belivers,&quot; and he literally only gets like two names into his list and Mike&apos;s like &quot;Wait, hold up, that guy&apos;s is a believer though?&quot; and Gary is just like &quot;Ya, but he disagrees with me about post-resurrection appearances!&quot;<br><br>Like, the degree to which Gary is disingenuous here, the <i>layers</i> of insincerity, it&apos;s breath-taking.

  67

• DA

  @davidhawkins7138 · 1 year ago

  Keep hammering on Habermas. Anything you can do to undermine this 13.2 lbs of pseudo-scholarly door stops is worthwhile.

  202