Are They Worth It? Lisa Eldridge Rouge Experience Lipsticks 2024

Comments · 635

• AI

  @Aijingaling · 1 year ago (edited) · pinned

  I forgot to mention that you can use the refills by themselves if you wanted to (in my second time filming this, hence the two outfits 😂) The refills do come with a lid but I’m not sure how well it will stay shut rattling around in a handbag. The twisting mechanism is a little more stiff without the outer component as well. However, the refill is definitely possible to use by itself!<br><br>Edit: Medici comparisons with blush and blush lightly are on community and instagram since a few of you have asked ❤

  98

• BR

  @brabalans348 · 1 year ago

  I think the Lisa Eldridge brand as a whole should be viewed as her ability as a successful makeup artist to indulge in creating products out of her own hearts desire. Suitable for her needs and what she thinks is missing from the overall market based on her perspectives. And personally I find this quite refreshing. A problem however is that because Lisa Eldridge represents something a bit more genuine and also kind as well as clever, intelligent and above all quite elegant - which differs from a lot of other influencers and above all influencer brands - there will very easily be created almost of a cult following. And people very easily feel compelled to buy pretty much everything she releases. Because they like her so much and want a piece of that. Now that is all good and well but like you show in this video. There are many shades and products that are quite similar. And I don’t think that her idea with her line is not that it is made to be consumed like you need everything she releases. It sort of contradicts what she is and stands for. <br><br>When it comes to this release I do welcome the concept of the forever lipstick case. My mother had a few of those when I was a child and I loved playing with them and probably they may very well have sparked my interest in makeup too. And I do enjoy that she goes all the way. And makes it super recyclable which is right up her alley since a pet peeve of hers has for the longest time been that recyclable most often means only a small part is… <br><br>My guess is that if this line becomes successful she will probably then phase out some of her non recyclable lipstick lines. Or phase in some of the shades in similar formulas made for her recyclable device.

  148

• DE

  @DEEv82 · 1 year ago

  My first thought was that many of them looked exactly the same. &nbsp;Thanks for the honesty.

  73

• TA

  @tamipie · 1 year ago

  I think your honesty is refreshing and helps to lower expectations a bit. So often people hear how fabulous all the things are, and when the box comes, there is often a disappointment, &nbsp;not because the products aren&apos;t good. They are good. But you hear over and over, wonderful, perfect, and amazing... and in the end, it&apos;s just lipstick. I do love this case. I did get one. And it is the one I think I will wear most often. Audrey looks very similar to Wonder Wheel to me, but Wonder Wheel is my favorite. I&apos;m that pale peachy complexion it is made for. I typically wait and buy after I&apos;ve seen a number of reviews. I want to hear some people say, &quot;This is what I didn&apos;t love... or here&apos;s why I&apos;m STILL using it.&quot; I also really appreciate comparisons. I know it takes time and energy, and I thank you for that.

  103

• JA

  @jazmeen04 · 1 year ago

  Comparisons is exactly what we are missing in the makeup industry. Every launch, makeup influencers tell us to buy the &quot;NEW BEST THING&quot;, because &quot;it&apos;s unlike anything we have ever tried&quot;. When in fact it&apos;s exactly like everything we have tried in the past. There are foundations that are 20yrs old, can you believe that. They are still good. I can&apos;t believe how many people get sucked into buying so many similar things in shiny new packaging. We really appreciate people like you.

  33

• SN

  @snestah · 1 year ago

  Here I am, watching this whole video even after buying the lipsticks already ❤

  125

• MA

  @Marchandpears · 1 year ago

  Brands should love (and be so lucky) to have such a comprehensive review as this - helps interested buyers like me make informed decisions with less risk of remorse ❤

  11

• EI

  @eikosato5297 · 1 year ago

  Ashes of Roses looks great on you! I really appreciate your videos because the shades look completely different on Asian skin tones than on Lisa 😅I’m gonna wait until she releases more shades and see if there’re shades that are more worth purchasing than Ashes of Roses.

  65

• AI

  @aixcarte10 · 1 year ago

  So far it is the best and most useful video about these lipsticks that I have seen. Thank you very much for it. If you have time maybe you could share a little comparison of blush and blush lightly (velvets) to medici. Thanks ❤

  119

• AL

  @alejandraornelas2506 · 1 year ago

  Thank you so much for all the comparisons and swatches. And for being honest with your review. Very useful!

  45

• JC

  @jcdmiranda · 1 year ago

  You honestly have perfect lips for this type of comparison video, thank you for the review! Personally, I loved this launch - not only is Lisa reviving a lost sustainable practice but she is also creating a keep-sake item meant to be treasured. I also really appreciate the fact that the refills are functioning lipsticks on their own, which is not usually the case with other brands. My guess is that she will slowly transition all of her lipstick formulas to this format overtime

  43

• PR

  @prettynostalgic-au · 1 year ago

  Her lipsticks are one of the only lipsticks that don&apos;t give me a weird reaction where my whole mouth peels. Never worked out what is causing it.

  4