CAUSAL PRINCIPLE: Does Everything That Begins to Exist Have a Cause? | Spencer Case, Ph. D.
404 views · Aug 1, 2026 · People & Blogs
Comments · 7
@westshot7338 · 1 month ago
what I think Dr. Case is missing about the philosophical argument for P2 is that the metaphysical possibility of instantiating an actual infinity opens the door to logical contradictions, from which anything follows (cf. principle of explosion). generally, theists don't commit themselves to a God who has the power to bring about a contradictory state of affairs - for example, God cannot create a rock so heavy he cannot lift it because that would be to imply that God is both maximally powerful and not maximally powerful simultaneously, from which anything follows (including the truth value of propositions like "atheism is true").<br><br>about his presentism point, it's an interesting one. though the presentist doesnt affirm that the past events strictly exist, what they might say is that there is nothing metaphysically impossible about a hypothetical world in which, every hour, a new atom is generated. in this hypothetical world, should it exist without a beginning, there would be an actually infinite number of atoms from which to construct hilberts hotel, even though those past events dont exist anymore on the presentist view. again, we open the door for contradictions / metaphysical absurdities.<br><br>I don't know that much about science, but I'll listen to that section and then the conversation on P1 tomorrow! Goodnight and God bless <3
1
@MrSamiGigi · 1 month ago
So much salad talk about the simple fact that the universe had a beginning.
@Baphomet101 · 1 month ago
The simple answer is NO. No explanation needed. The rest is just bullshit.
Up next

THE CASE FOR DEISM: Can the Universe Reveal a Creator? | Carlo Alvaro, Ph. D.
NT Podcast · 226 views

CAUSAL FINITISM: Can an Infinite Causal Regress Exist? | Robert C. Koons, Ph. D.
NT Podcast · 1.2K views

Anthropic and the Riemann Hypothesis: Here’s What Actually Happened
Ellie Sleightholm · 524K views

Two Theologies in America: Parts 1,2, & 3
Fred Ball · 51 views

Debunking William Lane Craig's Kalam Cosmological Argument | Matthew Adelstein
NT Podcast · 1.1K views

The REAL James Was NOT Who You Think | Dale C. Allison Jr, Ph. D.
NT Podcast · 740 views

Road to the Iron Bowl | Episode 9 | Week 3 Recap | Thursday, September 24th
Savor Broadcast Network · 47 views

Israel Is PANICKING Over Gaza Film - Courageous Israeli Journalist Gideon Levy Explains Why
Owen Jones · 327K views

Immanuel Kant's Philosophy - Bryan Magee & Geoffrey Warnock (1987)
Philosophy Overdose · 301K views

Uncovering the Archaeological Truth About King Solomon | Steven Ortiz, Ph. D.
NT Podcast · 976 views

This is What Really Happens to Russia When Putin Loses | Sarah Paine
Pyotr Kurzin | Geopolitics and Pyotr Kurzin | Clips · 872K views

The SHOCKING Truth About The Pyramids No One Tells You
The Diary Of A CEO Clips · 4.8M views

'A febrile moment for American democracy' | Simon Marks
LBC and LBC America · 525K views

The Kalam Argument Is LAUGHABLE: The Universe Needs No God | Richard Carrier, Ph. D.
NT Podcast · 1.5K views

James O'Brien reacts to Burnham's 'remarkable' conference speech
LBC and LBC UK Politics · 167K views

He Left Physics. Now He Has a New Explanation for Gravity
Curt Jaimungal · 116K views

‘There’s a real possibility of a backlash’ - Trump, AI and ‘end times fascism’
Channel 4 News · 134K views

41 Part 2. A Country You’ve Never Seen — Deported and Disappeared for Daring to Seek Safety
Living in the Promise Land: Immigrant Rights Pod · 9 views

“God Is a Delusion” - The Christopher Hitchens Speech That Made Me an Atheist
Skeptic Scriptura · 227K views

Brian Cox: Why black holes could hold the secret to time and space | Full Interview
Big Think · 5.2M views